Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Long Road to Success: Second-Generation Hmong Students and College Attainment

Mon, April 16, 10:35am to 12:05pm, Vancouver Convention Centre, Floor: Third Level, West Room 304

Abstract

Hmong tribal groups arrived in the U.S. as refugees fleeing persecution in Laos following the Vietnam War. As the least modernized group of all Southeast Asian refugees, they encountered great disadvantage in the United States, including in schools. Children were relatively underserved and remain an underperforming group compared with East Asian American and Euro American students, though a growing number of 2nd generation students now attend college (Ngo & Lee, 2007). However, literature detailing barriers and contributors to the achievement of Hmong American students is relatively scant. Moreover, we know little about Hmong student achievement because most of the literature has focused on obstacles to success. These barriers have included poverty, racism, and tracking into lower-level classes (Lee, 2001b; Thao, 2003); early marriage and kinship norms that clash with values embedded into schools (Lee, 2001a, 2001b); competitive and individualistic classroom environments (Timm, Chiang, & Finn, 1998); and negative teacher assessments of parent involvement (Adler, 2004). However, some of the literature has emphasized positive trends, including Hmong values emphasizing education as a means of upward mobility (Lee, 1997), positive achievement motivation, positive gender and cultural identity (Lee, 2001b), and additive strategies of biculturalism (McNall, Dunnigan, & Mortimer, 1994).

Research efforts focused on understanding the interrelationships between these factors is needed to offer a comprehensive model for assisting Hmong American achievement. With that in mind, the purpose of this study was to determine what led to the academic success of 2nd generation Hmong American college students, and to provide broad recommendations for practice and policy to create a pipeline to higher education for a larger segment of this population.

This paper utilized the achievement matrix (Author, 2010) as its theoretical model. The achievement matrix is a four-celled model created from two dimensions that together explain academic success or failure. One of these dimensions focuses on macro- to micro-level processes, while the other looks at influences that are internal or external to the ethnic group under study (roughly, “culture” or “structure” on the macro level, and individual factors or teacher characteristics on the micro level). The four domains in the achievement matrix are organized to demonstrate the interrelatedness of many factors leading to academic success or failure.

For the study, interviews were conducted with Hmong American 2nd generation college students, and the data underwent a content analysis to determine the common factors that accounted for their success. IRB approval was granted for this process. The data show that the factors leading to academic success were multifaceted, ranging from participation in college-going programs to positive relationships with teachers, to high parental expectations and a positive bicultural identity. The data also suggest that schools can be agents of positive influence in all of these areas. Specific implications for schools can include implementing a “college-going culture” (McClafferty, McDonough, & Nuñez, 2002), enabling deeper teacher-student relationships, encouraging parent and teacher collaboration, and establishing a culturally relevant curriculum. Such multifaceted efforts have the best chance of encouraging broader and higher achievement in Hmong American students.

Author