Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Submission Type
Browse By Descriptors
Help
About Vancouver
Personal Schedule
Sign In
This paper reports on research in the teacher education setting in England, a setting strongly characterised by New Public Management reforms and the explicit recasting of professionality and the cultural identity of the teacher. The paper turns around the concept of ‘professional creativity’ and draws on ideas both more recently published translated texts from Vygotsky concerning creativity and concept formation and also from Engeström’s third generation of activity theory
In the English-speaking world, according to Williams (1965), we can trace a historical shift in the meaning of creativity away from the divine towards an emphasis on human capacity, practical making and the fashioning of a collective, conceptual inheritance through certain kinds of work. One interpretation of recent policy in UK public services generally - and in teaching and teacher education more specifically - is that there has been a rhetorical shift backwards towards creativity as a quasi-divine attribute present in individuals who ‘deliver’ reforms and reform practices in ‘inspirational’ or charismatic ways. The paper begins with a brief analysis of the rhetoric of recent policy and research traditions in England concerning creativity in educational work and the figure of the ‘creative teacher’, in particular. The analysis draws on a range of sociocultural theoretical tools, especially theories of collective creativity and Williams’s historical account of cultural development.
The paper then goes on to consider a practical alternative to the dominant understandings of creativity in educational discourse in England by focusing on a study of systemic change and development in the teacher education setting. The research – framed as a variation of the Developmental Work Research design – sought to stimulate change in practices by donating the conceptual tools of activity theory to English Language Arts teacher participants in order for them to develop a historical consciousness of their collective activity and to come up with new ideas and ways of working. Engeström (1993) describes this process as the identification of ‘sediments and buds’ where the sediments are unconscious, multi-voiced layers of historical activity and buds are the opportunities for change and development that are perceived to be accessible. The paper asserts the importance of at least two definitions of history and historical consciousness in the change process: the level of ‘general history’, as Scribner put it (1985), and the micro-level of the history of specific activity systems and settings. It is through a dialectical understanding of activity across these two levels of history at minimum that developmental potentials may be realised and also by which genuine innovation may be distinguished from mere novelty. In order to achieve this end – of collective creativity, conceptual growth and the learning of the system – the paper argues that the semiotic freedom of participants is an essential precondition and that this enhanced form of agency is in contradiction with the changed ground rules for English Language Arts teacher professionality under New Public Management in the UK.