Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The current state of mathematics formative assessments in the United States as provided by test publishers

Mon, April 16, 12:25 to 1:55pm, Pan Pacific, Floor: Lobby Level, Oceanview 1&2

Abstract

Principals and district officials often look to the test publishers to quickly identify tools and systems to increase student performance and respond to the ever-changing demands of current state and national policies. Therefore, it is often the case that the test publishers define what the best answer is in these situations, rather than instructors, schools, districts and states themselves. Formative assessment is yet another instructional method that test publishers have chosen to market in their own ways on the private market. As the use of formative assessments produced by professional test publishers become more widespread in American classrooms, there is a need to better understand how these tools are currently being leveraged from a pedagogical and practical perspective, as well as to assess potential future trends in the field.

The purpose of this study was to examine the current status, definition of, and possible future direction of mathematics formative assessment development and use by a wide variety of commercial test publishers and developers. Our research investigates what specific mathematics formative assessment tools are currently available for purchase from test publishers and developers and how they are being used within the nation’s schools to improve instruction and student learning. A brief overview of our methodology follows.

The combination of a circumscribed literature review and results from a in-depth principal survey resulted in an initial short list of the industry’s prominent players in the mathematics formative assessment marketplace. From this short list, key contacts were identified for each test publisher through a review their websites along with emails and phone calls. The identified individuals were asked to complete a on-line survey that asked for the following for each math formative assessment product: Name of product, grades the product covered, current geographic market presence, and the medium of delivery, how the publisher sees the classroom use of resulting mathematics formative assessment data (e.g. to inform instruction, to plan daily activity), and if professional development training is provided to administer, score, analyze, and interpret the math formative assessments system. Phone interviews were conducted to glean further insight into the survey responses.

Results indicated three general categories of formative assessment tools developed by test publishers: 1) systems with fixed, off-the-shelf formative assessment instruments; 2) platforms that allow for fully customized forms; 3) however, most were a combination of both fixed and customizable instruments. Although these test publishers have developed powerful systems, the majority of them view the system as just a tool. In general, they emphasize the proper application of these tools in support of a holistic formative approach. Therefore, they expressed that the professional development of teachers and administrators as to what is appropriate formative assessment practice is should be prioritized and supported by education policy makers and administrative leaders.

The responses to the survey and phone interviews offered by the assessment developers helped ascertain a first look of the current status of implementation and various approaches to mathematics formative assessment instruments in the United States.

Author