Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Experiencing Continuous and Interactional Coherence in Initial Teacher Education

Sat, April 14, 12:25 to 1:55pm, Vancouver Convention Centre, Floor: Second Level, East Room 2&3

Abstract

Theoretical Framework and Objectives
Research suggests that powerful and effective teacher education programs need to be coherent (Brouwer & Korthagen, 2005; Boyd et al., 2006, 2009; Darling-Hammond et al., 2005; Grossman, et al. 2008; Zeichner, 2011). However, the conception of coherence and the means of developing such coherence is still relatively new and underdeveloped (Grossman et al., 2008). In this paper, we draw upon Dewey’s notion of continuity and interaction (Dewey, 1938) to both conceptualize and then analyze coherence in teacher education. We argue that these are the continuous and interactional aspects of experience, which are often regarded as central factors in creating coherent initial education programs but have not yet been examined directly. The continuous aspect refers to how previous experiences influence current perceptions, and the interactional aspect concerns how different situations interact and how they interact to promote coherence.
In this paper, in order to develop a richer, more methodologically grounded conception of coherence, we draw upon our data to investigate whether students perceive program coherence (continuous and interactional) differently across teacher education programs, and examine which factors contribute to explanations of variance.
Methods
We take both a quantitative and qualitative approach to examine coherence, drawing from program data as well as survey data in order to examine these features of coherence. Our data include quantitative analyses of Norwegian students’ responses to a questionnaire survey conducted during Dec 2010 and Jan 2011.
Data sources
928 first year teacher education students for grades 1-10 in Norway (total population = 2200) completed digital surveys. Variables included here: Reasons for choosing teacher education (4 subscales), Previous experience, Study habits, Professional commitment, and Program Coherence. A 2-factor variable for perceptions of program coherence was created consisting of one factor that measures coherence in a continuity perspective (future profession, 4 items, a=.72) and one in an interactional perspective (theory-practice during education, 5 items, a=.76).
Results
Students who report higher values on interest in the educational program as a reason for choosing teacher education as well as already identifying with the teaching profession, also have a tendency to report higher values on perception of especially continuous program coherence but also interactional. There is a negative relationship between perceptions of coherence and having chosen teacher education more by chance or for practical / economic reasons. Analyses also investigate differences between teacher education institutions.
Significance
Research on coherence is still in its infancy. This study contributes to knowledge by (a) developing the concept of coherence through ways of measuring students’ perceptions of continuous and interactional coherence and (b) investigating this in relation to other important variables (students’ own background and input) and contexts (characteristics of educational programs). The study contributes to knowledge about recruitment into teacher education and can also be of use when developing selection strategies.

Authors