Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

A Hermeneutics of the Teleology of Education in the 21st Century

Sat, April 14, 10:35am to 12:05pm, Pan Pacific, Floor: Restaurant Level, Pacific Rim 1

Abstract

The thesis of this paper is that secular norms embedded within modern public education in the United States are contributing to a system that leaves young people entering adulthood woefully unprepared for the realities of life in contemporary postmodern society. Simply, we are failing to prepare young people to respond thoughtfully to the most pressing problems facing humanity. The situation is well stated by Norman Wirzba (2006):

Consider the fact that in our information and technological age, when we purportedly have more knowledge than ever before, we are witnesses to and agents of the most widespread ecological destruction and communal disintegration the world has ever known. Something is desperately wrong with an education system that does not adequately prepare us to consider, address, and learn the basic skills of our life together, that does not teach us in the arts of conservation, protection, celebration, and maintenance.

The paper is a critical analysis of the relationship between the tacit purpose of public education and ecological destruction and communal disintegration. As a hermeneutic analysis of teleology, the paper provides an interpretation of the end goals of public education from a post-secular orientation. From a post-secular lens, religious narratives and practices are symbolic and ritualized expressions of historical human wisdom regarding key relationships of existence- relationships between individuals in social communities, and relationships between individuals and the natural environment.
The problem is that separation of church and state, and corresponding modern constructs of secular and sacred, are effectively preventing humanity’s historical knowledge of living in community and in harmony with the environment from inclusion in the curriculum of public schools. Thus, the most profound historical texts of ancient wisdom and knowledge based on millenniums of human experience and oral tradition are considered unacceptable, or irrelevant, because they are at best considered to be sacred and at worst metaphysical nonsense. This is unfortunate because at the time the texts comprising the world’s wisdom traditions were written, the concepts of sacred and secular, as we think of them today, did not exist. Ancient writers were simply communicating with the only linguistic and intellectual tools available to them.
Many contemporary writers including, among others, bell hooks (2004), Wendell Barry (2002), and Norman Wirzba (2006) have chronicled the failures of American education to prepare future generations for sustainable living with one another and with the environment in an inclusive and socially just manner. The paper summarizes some of the social arguments from these education critics. For purposes of this paper, the work of these scholars’ is interpreted as a challenge to modern sacred and secular distinctions and is followed with a call for a postmodern understanding of the subjective relationship between meaning and text in all language. Using the post-secular hermeneutic style of Richard Kearny (2001, 2011) as a guide, the paper provides an example of how an ancient text, the Old Testament of the Bible in this case, may provide guidance for a new vision for the role of public education.

Author