Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Submission Type
Browse By Descriptors
Help
About Vancouver
Personal Schedule
Sign In
While early reading ability is closely related to code-related skills (e.g., letter identification, phonemic awareness), reading comprehension ability in the upper elementary grades is much more closely associated with language ability (Catts et al., 2006; Vellutino, Tunmer, Jaccard, & Chen 2007) the effects of which are long-lasting (Dickinson & Tabors, 2001). Unfortunately, the field has little to offer teachers with respect to providing intensive language support to enhance reading comprehension. SFL provides a framework for engaging students in using the structure of language to comprehend and discuss ideas in text, as well as support their writing. We present two comparative case studies (Merriam, 2001) of the application of FGA with English Language Learners in grades 4 and 5, focusing on teaching word choice through investigating processes and attitudes in text.
SFL is a theory of language that links language form and meaning in contexts of use; grammar is a network of linguistic choices as opposed to a set of rules to be followed (Halliday, 1994; Schleppegrell, 2001; 2004). The theory provides teachers with resources for talking about the wording in text, providing an avenue for explicitly supporting reading comprehension.
Professional development supported teachers in adopting SFL metalanguage for talking with students about the texts they read. This paper presents analyses of the lessons two teachers subsequently developed to support students in thinking about the effect of authors’ word choices. Lesson one focused on process types in a text to highlight narrative events in relation to textual themes. In lesson 2, teachers and students analyzed the ways in which attitudes were conveyed by the author using amplification (Martin & White, 2005). The instruction was observed and videotaped, and students’ writing was collected.
Video and field-notes were coded to identify: (a) how SFL metalanguage was used in the lesson to reference and/or analyze the text, (b) how the teacher linked with other text comprehension tools, and (c) how the students were prepared to write. The students’ discourse and writing were analyzed for evidence of children's appropriation of the language features in focus.
Strengths and limitations were seen in the teaching of both linguistic features. Talk about processes helped students summarize the major events, see changes in a character's feelings, and attend to the effect of process on meaning. Talk about attitudes offered rich opportunites to engage in text analyses and students' writing reflected robust uptake of strategies for expressing attitudes. On the other hand, the cases also reveal ways in which the enactment of FGA can undermine sense-making with text, and can inform further work to strengthen pedagogies that use linguistic metalanguage to support comprehension.
While there have been a number of calls for the use of an SFL perspective (Athanases & de Oliveira, 2008; Godley et al. 2006; Fang, 2006), there is virtually no research investigating its application to reading comprehension with young children. Our analyses suggest how SFL tools can provide the greatest leverage in the classroom and be applied in productive, meaningful ways.