Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Promoting Collaborative Approaches to Developing Effective Teachers: The Contribution of Cultural-Historical Activity Theory

Mon, April 16, 10:35am to 12:05pm, Vancouver Convention Centre, Floor: Second Level, West Room 220

Abstract

This paper argues for the potential of cultural-historical activity theory (CHAT) in promoting and understanding collaborative approaches to the development of effective teachers. We propose a shift in how we think about collaboration. Instead of seeing inter-organizational collaboration as ‘boundary crossing’, we think of collaboration in terms of expertise which is distributed across local networks and which can be drawn upon to support teacher development (Edwards, 2010).

We stress the key CHAT methodological concept of ‘double stimulation’ (Vygotsky, 1978) – whereby tools are “donated” to research participants for them to make sense of in their future-oriented development work. Local systems of the kind that we find in bounded systems such as schools can be limited and ‘exclusionary’ (Sennett, 1999). CHAT can help to open such systems. We can begin to think of pre-service teacher education as open local networks of distributed expertise and mutual engagement focused on a student teacher’s learning trajectory.

Data Sources
We draw on studies recently undertaken in a research centre in England: a study of school-university partnerships in England (Edwards & Mutton, 2006); and an intervention study, in the tradition of Developmental Work Research, into a pre-service teacher education programme (Ellis, 2008).

Findings and Significance
Findings from the first study show that school-university partnership responses to problems of genuine collaboration in the preparation of teachers often sustain very rigid practices in schools that inhibit responsive, flexible collaborations. These rigid systems seem to produce tightly guarded boundaries resulting in limited inter-professional collaboration.

Findings from the second study (an intervention study that involved a collaboration between a university-based teacher educator-researcher, teachers from four schools, and student teachers) show the creation of more flexible and open knowledge-creating networks. All participants were co-researchers working on aspects of English teaching. Using CHAT tools helped teachers to analyse the systems that are set up to support learning and to consider how systems might be improved.

Taken together, these studies demonstrates the power of collaboration that erodes boundaries, whether hierarchical or between schools. They exemplify how schools and universities can operate as systems of distributed expertise that can be harnessed for common enterprises. They include a focus on joint knowledge production, different expertise in different parts of the network, and contribute to the professional knowledge base by making professional knowledge public.

Implications
In England, pre-service teacher education partnerships were initially driven by accountability and managed through politeness so systems were rarely disrupted. Schools, in England and Wales at least, have been largely independent organisations in a purchaser-provider environment since the introduction of local management of schools. We suggest that the overarching problem is that we have been thinking of collaboration in terms of partnerships and boundary crossing and not in terms of networks of expertise. Promoting the growth of social systems such as professional-academic networks focused on teacher development can be richly supported by CHAT-informed approaches to collaboration.

Authors