Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Individual and Collaborative Journals as Tools for Revision of Ideas in Science Inquiry

Mon, April 16, 2:15 to 3:45pm, Pan Pacific, Floor: Lobby Level, Oceanview 1&2

Abstract

Objective
Our objective is to study an approach to science inquiry instruction that centers on a challenge-based learning cycle (Schwartz, Lin, Brophy, & Bransford, 1999) that features multiple opportunities for formal reflection and revision of ideas.

Theoretical Framework
According to the National Research Council, “the ability to examine one’s own knowledge and conceptual frameworks, to evaluate them in relation to new information or competing alternative frameworks, and to alter them by a deliberate and conscious effort are key scientific practices” (NRC, 2007, p. 27). Revision of ideas is extremely important in promoting students’ metacognitive learning and helping students develop a reflective “habit of mind” (NRC, 2000). Metacognitive processes such as this require specialized support in the classroom (White & Frederiksen, 1998).
In one model of curricular design, SMART environments engage students in repeated cycles of design, feedback, and revision. Given appropriate supports, students were able to reflect upon their thinking and revise their work (Barron et al., 1998; Vye et al., 1998). The current study extends this work, exploring the curricular supports that foster the revision of ideas. Specifically, we look at scaffolding in the form of individual and collaborative journals.

Methods and Data Sources
Eight classes and 129 5th grade students participated in a 12-week inquiry-based science unit, the Isopod Habitat Challenge, in which they were challenged to design an optimum habitat for isopods. Students engaged in authentic science practice in the sense that they conducted sustained, original inquiry and had agency in determining the course of their inquiry.
At the unit’s start, students individually recorded their initial response to the challenge in journals. This was followed by two opportunities to revise their ideas, the first after several rounds of experimentation and the second following print-based research. At each point, students responded to following prompts:
• What do you know (or think you know) about isopods?
• What do isopods need in their habitat, and why do they need those things?
• What questions do you have that must be answered before you set up your habitat?
After individually responding, students worked in small groups to respond to similar prompts in collaborative journals. In culmination, each group designed (and built) a habitat for isopods. Data sources for this study include the written individual and collaborative journals.

Findings
As the unit progressed, students demonstrated more factual knowledge about isopods. Their questions became more focused on the overarching challenge, specifically addressing issues related to habitat construction. Additionally, their ideas about what isopods need became more specific over time. A frequent initial response to this prompt was that isopods need water because all organisms need water. By the final revision, students were more likely to respond that isopods need moist soil because they have gills.

Scholarly Significance
Formal opportunities to revise thinking are often absent in classrooms, yet they are invaluable for student learning. This study provides a model for how revision of ideas might be scaffolded in science inquiry experiences through the use of individual and collaborative journaling.

Authors