Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Submission Type
Browse By Descriptors
Help
About Vancouver
Personal Schedule
Sign In
While scientific argumentation is acknowledged as a central epistemic practice, there is disagreement about how best to support it in classrooms (Bricker & Bell, 2008; Cavagnetto, 2010; Duschl, Schweingruber, & Shouse, 2007). I describe a method for design and analysis that forefronts argument’s epistemic function. The scientific enterprise is uncertain and open-ended. Argument supports scientific communities in building not only knowledge, but the machinery for knowing: a mutually-stabilizing network of statements, investigations, measures, and graphs taken to adequately represent the world (Latour & Woolgar, 1986; Pickering, 1995). Through this process, what counts as an argument is defined, so conventional forms of argument have evolved over historical scientific activity (Bazerman, 1988). Similarly, for students to develop a “grasp of practice” (Ford, 2008), they must participate in activity that situates the need for the practice and its refinement.
Therefore, rather than conceptualizing students’ participation in argumentation using particular forms, I focus on argument’s function, namely, the stabilization of:
(1) a community’s machinery for knowing
(2) what knowledge is taken-as-shared.
I ask how students can appropriate this function and leverage it in scientific activity, illustrating this approach with data from a design study in an urban third grade classroom. I focus on a seven-week investigation during which students modeled areas of a backyard system with Wisconsin Fast Plants™, controlling exposure to light and seeking to determine where they grew best.
Central to instructional design were conjectures about the potential of activity to support the development of knowledge and the means for knowing. We engaged students in familiar, functional forms of talk (telling what one thinks and why, questioning, agreeing, and disagreeing) using public, recurrent structures for claim-making (Figure 1). Activity was designed to provoke uncertainty or conflict and provide resources that stretched talk to disciplinary functions and forms. For example, the plant investigation constructed a need for students to first develop, then contrast, and eventually privilege particular measures through argument.
Analysis consists of three phases (Table 2), based on accounts of development linking microgenetic, sociogenetic, and ontogenetic change (Saxe, 2002). First, evidence of opportunities for developing (1) the machinery for knowing and (2) taken-as-shared knowledge were located in video records. For example, early on, one student challenged another’s use of the term “big,” eliciting an opportunity to differentiate attributes such as plant height and size of leaves. I next asked whether these opportunities translated into community development of acceptable warrants [evidence of shifts in (1)] or shared assumptions [evidence of shifts in (2)]. Students increasingly differentiated attributes and justified the use of one attribute--number of seeds—signaling an emerging consensus of reproduction as a criterion of successful growth. Finally, I explored generalization, using interviews to evaluate students’ construction and evaluation of new, stand-alone arguments.
The initial application of this approach suggests it is a useful tool for designing activity that makes the epistemic basis of argument visible, identifying the scientific machinery students were successful in building (i.e. developing measures) and what remained opaque or unresolved, and supporting the redesign of activity systems.