Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Welfare, Place, Standards, Identity, and Mobility in Canadian Rural Education

Sat, April 14, 12:25 to 1:55pm, Vancouver Convention Centre, Floor: First Level, East Ballroom C

Abstract

There has been a tension in educational policy in recent decades between a growing awareness of the importance of factors outside school on educational performance. These “externalities” include, social factors which influence educational outcomes, historical factors which systematically position identifiable populations as “other” to the educational project and finally what Edward Soja calls spatial justice or the idea that resources are unequally distributed across geographic space. One such space is that which is defined as rural and there is an established/embedded historic awareness of rurality as an economic, cultural and educational problem space.
As each of these contextual factors (for lack of a better word) are found to influence and reflect differential educational performance, there has been a corollary movement to improve educational equity through the use of standardized curricula and assessment tools. While the North American rural education community has long defended community and small schools often claiming that authentic and desirable educational outcomes that matter are actually better in rural places, there has been a parallel movement to raise standardized test scores in rural areas. In other words school improvement is not defined in local terms but rather in terms of state, provincial, national and international standards. This tension has played out in rural education with considerable force in recent years. Published standardized test scores typically show rural places to be performing below the level of urban and suburban schools. Right-wing think tanks that rank schools in league table fashion often find their most challenged “sink” schools in rural communities.
Edward Soja's (2010) idea of spatial justice provides a set of conceptual tools to evaluate the way that social inequality is social, historical and geographic all at the same time. This paper argues that rural educators who are seriously interested in improving educational well-being and life/living conditions in rural communities would do well to attend to the way that poverty and educational performance are spatialized. This paper draws on contemporary conceptualizations of space and place (Lefebvre, 1991; Massey, 2007) and Green et al's (2010) idea of rural social space, which suggests a three part conception of space which combines social, economic and environmental dimensions. This more complex conception of space and place can, I argue, take us beyond commonplace deficit discourses around rurality (Donehower et al, 2007) as well as the problems of essentializing place, characteristic of scholarship in the place-based education tradition (e.g., Nespor, 2009).

Author