Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Using artifact-based interviews to study the development of computational thinking in interactive media design

Mon, April 16, 8:15 to 9:45am, Sheraton Wall Centre, Floor: Third Level, North Junior Ballroom C

Abstract

Computational thinking is a phrase that has received considerable attention over the past several years – but there is little agreement about what computational thinking encompasses, and even less agreement about strategies for assessing the development of computational thinking in young people (NRC, 2010). We are interested in the ways that design-based learning activities – in particular, through the programming of interactive media – support the development of computational thinking in young people. Part of this interest is fuelled by the growing availability of tools that enable young people to design their own interactive media. But, more importantly, this interest is rooted in a commitment to learning through design activities, a constructionist approach to learning that highlights the importance of young people engaging in the development of external artifacts (Kafai & Resnick, 1996).

Over the past several years, we have developed a computational thinking framework that emerged from our studies of the activities of interactive media designers. Our particular context of interest is Scratch – a programming environment that enables young people to create their own interactive stories, games, and simulations, and then share those creations in an online community with other young programmers from around the world (Resnick et al., 2009). Our framework is based on several years of observing activity in the Scratch online community and in Scratch workshops. Observation has been instrumental in helping us track the longitudinal development of creators, with project portfolios spanning weeks to several years, and workshops have been instrumental in understanding the practices of the creator-in-action.

The first part of the paper describes the key dimensions of our computational thinking framework: computational concepts (the concepts designers engage with as they program, such as iteration, parallelism, etc.), computational practices (the practices designers develop as they engage with the concepts, such as debugging one’s projects or remixing others’ work), and computational perspectives (the perspectives the designers form about the world around them, such as seeing computation as an expressive medium and feeling empowered to ask questions about the technical world around them).

The second part of the paper describes our approaches to assessing these dimensions. Our initial work using project content analysis as a means of assessing computational thinking quickly revealed its limitations. For example, the presence of a code element in a project was not necessarily an indicator that the designer understood the code element sufficiently to be able to use it in other contexts. In response, we developed an artifact-based interview approach to assessing computational thinking. We describe its benefits for assessing understanding of computational concepts and cultivation of computational practices, and its challenges for assessing the development of computational perspectives. We share our evolving interview protocol, analyze its strengths and weaknesses, and present excerpts from the 24 computational thinking assessment interviews we conducted with young Scratchers.

Authors