Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Hispanic-White Achievement Gaps in the Five States With the Largest Hispanic Student Populations

Sat, April 14, 12:25 to 1:55pm, Marriott Pinnacle, Floor: Third Level, Dundarave

Abstract

This paper examines the White-Hispanic reading and mathematics score gaps at grade 4 and 8 as measured by NAEP according to English language learner and family income status in the five states with the largest number of Hispanic students (California, Texas, Florida, New York, and Illinois). Hispanics students now account for about 20 percent of the U.S. student population, and about 70 percent of U.S. Hispanics live in these five states.
Data from the National Assessment of Educational Progress state assessments in reading and mathematics at grades 4 and 8 have consistently shown a gap in performance between White and Hispanic students that ranged from about 21 to 26 points on the NAEP 0-500 scales since the early 1990s (Hemphill & Vanneman 2011). Gaps have also existed at the state level, but these gaps were not always comparable to the national gap. At grade 8 mathematics in 2009, for example, the states had the following gaps: California, 33; Florida, 15; Illinois, 25; New York, 32; Texas, 24. The gaps in California and New York were larger than the national gap of 26 points, while the gap in Florida was smaller (ibid.).
It has been argued that the small size of the gap in Florida is the result of educational policies that could produce similar results if emulated by other states (Ladner & Murray 2008). In addition, the average score for Hispanic students in Florida in 2009 was above the national average for Hispanic students for both grades and both subjects (ibid.). However, score gaps narrowed in Florida since the late 1990s in grade mathematics only (Hemphill & Vanneman 2011).
Differences in score gaps might be explained better by considering other factors, such as relative percentages of low-income students, who traditionally have lower scores than higher-income students, and, for Hispanic students in particular, relative percentages of English language learners (ELL students). For example, according to NAEP data from the 2009 grade 8 mathematics assessment, 32 percent of California’s Hispanic students were ELL, scoring 33 points below their non ELL Hispanic counterparts, while in Florida 13 percent of Hispanic students were ELL, scoring 37 points below their non ELL Hispanic counterparts.
This paper examines the Hispanic-White achievement gaps in the five states in terms of the subgroups generated by NAEP two background variables, ELL and family income status. Interactions between these two variables will also be examined. This analysis will give a more meaningful picture of student performance in the five states.
Comparisons will be made using NAEP 2011 reading and mathematics results, supplemented by comparisons to results from prior assessments when appropriate. NAEP data are available for all five states for both grades and subjects back to 2003, and, for all states except Illinois, back to 1992 for grade 4 reading and mathematics, back to 1990 for grade 8 mathematics, and back to 1998 for grade 8 reading.

Authors