Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Submission Type
Browse By Descriptors
Help
About Vancouver
Personal Schedule
Sign In
Two contexts will be used to examine learning and reasoning processes in contexts in which these processes are supported through use of interactive discourse: individual tutoring of students by an experienced tutor to develop expertise in solving problems in engineering (Frederiksen, 2011a); and clinical interviews with patients as contexts of diagnostic reasoning in medicine (Frederiksen, Donin, & Koschmann, 2011b; Frederiksen, 2008). Both contexts involve two-person dialogue as the means of communication. The aim of the research was to trace learning, reasoning and problem-solving processes in these interactive situations; the contributions the participants made to the conversational structure of the discourse; and how the discourse content supported the acquisition and application of knowledge and competency in reasoning and solving problems. A similar approach has been applied previously to interactive discourse within a problem-based learning group in medicine (Frederiksen, 1999).
A sociolinguistic model of conversational actions was applied to analyze the structure of the dialogue, and models of cognitive representations (propositions, knowledge representations, schema theory) were applied to analyze the content of the discourse as it related to co-occurring processes of reasoning and problem solving. Results showed how the content and interactive structure of the discourse functioned together to support cognitive processes of learning, reasoning and problem solving.
In tutoring in engineering, the tutor modeled problem-solving methods for the student through dialogue in a context of solving a problem example. In subsequent sessions involving solving new problems, the student “took command” of the discourse while the tutor used the discourse to provide evaluations and coaching support to facilitate the student’s refinement of his/her knowledge and develop independent skill in solving problems in the domain. The tutorial discourse enabled the tutor to adapt to the student by shifting from modeling to coaching each of which was reflected in a particular pattern of conversational interaction.
In the clinical interview situation in medicine, a medical student, resident, or experienced physician interacted with a “standardized patient” to conduct a clinical interview in a natural manner in an examination room. Conversational analysis of the clinical dialogue revealed how the discourse was organized into conversational exchanges and sequences, and analysis of the content of the exchanges revealed how the subject used the interview to elicit information from the SP to build a “case representation” and, based on the case evidence, apply diagnostic knowledge to generate a set of diagnostic hypotheses to account for the clinical evidence (the “differential diagnosis”), evaluate each diagnostic hypothesis and arrive at a preferred (“leading”) diagnosis, and finally produce a treatment plan including subsequent lab tests.
The results obtained in these two studies demonstrate how discourse in use in these situations functioned as a medium for social interaction, communication, learning, thinking, reasoning, and problem solving activity in contexts of acquiring or applying knowledge. In both cases, the results show how application of complementary approaches to analysis of the discourse provided evidence of how the discourse interaction functioned to support learning, the construction and application of knowledge, and the development of expertise.