Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Troubling Equity in Australian Education Policy and Research

Fri, April 13, 2:15 to 3:45pm, Vancouver Convention Centre, Floor: Second Level, West Room 220

Abstract

This paper provides an analysis of the recent elevation of the importance of equitable student outcomes within Australian education policy and research. It argues that this re-imagination of the relationship between ‘private troubles’ and ‘public issues’ (Mills 1959) relies on a deficit account of the private – often confirmed by narrowly-focused empirical research – and on its rehabilitation for the public good. For example, student aspirations, once the preserve of individuals and their immediate families and communities (Anderson et al. 1980; Anderson & Vervoorn 1983), have become the focus of Australian higher education policy (Sellar, Gale & Parker 2011), and their manipulation (to favour higher education) among under-represented groups directed towards giving Australia a competitive edge in the global knowledge economy. Similarly, returning to study has now become a condition for teenage mothers to continue to receive welfare payments (Australian Government 2011), informed by research which suggests that their enhanced qualifications will ensure that their children attain higher levels of academic achievement (James 2002). This ‘tough love’ account of students' private lives is in stark contrast to a sociology of education that emphasizes the deficits of public institutions and the reproduction of advantage and disadvantage by education systems (Bourdieu & Passeron 1977) through the privileging of certain knowledge forms (Said 1978; Connell 2007) and ways of knowing and being. The paper concludes that to shift attention back on to the public arena requires a new accounting of the markers of education distinction in contemporary times. It identifies four as mobility, aspiration, voice and transition and proposes corresponding social capacities that students and their institutions now need to develop: to cultivate networks, imagine futures, narrate experiences, and navigate change.

Author