Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Descriptor
Search Tips
Annual Meeting Theme
Exhibitors
About Philadelphia
About AERA
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Published descriptions and qualitative studies of lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) educators’ experiences of discrimination, anecdotal data, and decisions in court cases (Eckes & McCarthy, 2008) suggested that discrimination has existed against sexual minorities in the education profession. The 2007 National Survey (Smith, et al 2006) yielded valuable quantitative data, highlighted in Smith, et al (2008) and Wright (2010a, 2010b) indicating a difficult climate for LGBT educators, especially those working with younger students. In 2011, the researchers again surveyed LGBT educators across the country using the National Survey of Educators’ School Climates 2011 (Smith & Wright, 2010), which was a revised version of the 2007 instrument. One main purpose of repeating the study in 2011 was to measure if any significant change had occurred.
In the 2007 study, much of the statistically significant data reported related to the workplace climate for LGBT educators based on the school level at which they worked (Wright, 2010B). A conclusion drawn from these results indicated a connection between the experiences of LGBT educators and a common misperception among the general public correlating homosexuality and pedophilia. In order to compare the results of the 2007 and 2011 studies, SPSS ANOVA program was used to detect significant differences in several areas based on the reported school level using the following survey items: teacher intervention on homophobic remarks, administrator intervention on homophobic remarks, teachers’ employment risk if “out” to administrators, teachers’ employment risk if “out” to students, the amount of professional development experienced around the topics of 1) LGBT students, and 2) LGBT professionals in the school setting. In 2007, significant differences were seen (p<.05) in employment risk if out to students and administrators. In 2011, significant differences (p < .05) were seen for only the item of employment risk if out to students. Post hoc results from both years demonstrated that overall, LGBT teachers of younger students were more fearful of losing their employment due to being out to students, although more in 2011 felt comfortable being honest with their supervisors, which shows a slight improvement in workplace climate. That part of the hypothesis was supported. No significant differences were found among the other items in both iterations of the survey, although descriptive data painted a disturbing picture of the lack of professional development for all educators on LGBT issues in general and of the lack of consistent intervention by teachers and administrators on homophobic remarks made in the school setting, which showed little improvement from 2007 to 2011.
Much of the research indicates that bullying behaviors begin in the late elementary years and increase throughout middle school. If these are the schools at which LGBT educators feel the most concerned about their job safety due to being out, these students are likely to feel increased isolation without positive LGBT grown-ups as models. LGBT students (and LGBT teachers) will therefore feel more supported when school and district administrators provide school personnel with professional development geared towards understand the issues of LBT people.