Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Coach’s View of Discourse: What Does the Low-Inference Discourse Observation Show Us and Not Show Us?

Mon, April 7, 2:15 to 3:45pm, Convention Center, Floor: 100 Level, 109A

Abstract

1. Objectives: Changes in teaching practice are complex and take time. On-the-ground observations of such changes by coaches who are deeply involved in individual teachers’ practice can provide substantive insights that may or may not accord with what we see in a low-inference tool like the LIDO. Therefore, the final presentation in this symposium will provide a qualitative, engaged view of how classroom realities accord with the findings of the LIDO.

We have worked in a number of the classrooms that are part of this study. In this presentation we will discuss six of them, three each in two different states where the research for this Reading for Understanding project was conducted. For each one, we will briefly present its LIDO profile for the two early and two late observations. We will then discuss ways in which the profiles are in accord (or are not in accord) with our close-up view of (a) the particular teacher’s development in using the tools of discussion and classroom discourse more generally, (b) the students’ development over time in participating in the structures for talk and discussion that the teacher set up.

2. Framework: Our approach to understanding teacher development and classroom development is rooted in our years of experience as teachers and coaches. We are sensitive to the individual needs and characteristics of particular teachers and students, and are reflective about how they take on the tasks of using classroom discourse, a process which can be psychologically challenging and organizationally challenging. We will bring our hands-on and grounded knowledge of praxis to the conversation about both the merits of the LIDO, and what it cannot do.

3&4. Methods and Data sources: This presentation will rely on data derived from the LIDO coding and on our coaching logs and first person experience. We will use a narrative approach to characterize the development of six individual teachers and their classrooms, providing vignettes that capture our own qualitative perspectives on what the LIDO can reveal and not reveal.

5&6. Conclusions and Significance: The picture we will present is complex. There are aspects of the profiles, derived from counts of simple vs. extended student responses, teacher moves, and rare but revealing student response types, that do accord very well with our subjective evaluation of where teachers are in their progress towards skillful use of discussion. On the other hand, there are symptoms and signs of development in teacher practice and in student engagement and reasoning that the LIDO cannot detect. We finish with a reflection on what it would take to bring this low-inference tool closer to our first-person experience as coaches.

Authors