Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Are Teachers Born or Made? Linking Teachers’ Personality and Self-Efficacy With Effective Teaching

Sun, April 6, 8:15 to 10:15am, Convention Center, Floor: 100 Level, 113A

Abstract

Objectives. Considerable research has been conducted based on the assumption that teachers’ psychological characteristics are related to the quality of their teaching. The purpose of this paper is to report a meta-analysis that examines the links between two psychological characteristics—personality and self-efficacy—and objective measures of teaching effectiveness.

Theoretical Framework. The research is built on personality theories (e.g., Big Five theory) and the motivation-situated theory of self-efficacy, which suggests that our personal efficacy beliefs influence our behaviors.

Methods. To identify relevant studies, we: (a) searched published and unpublished sources using six online databases, (b) reviewed the reference lists of all studies identified, and (c) sent email requests to authors of identified studies to collect unpublished data. To be included, studies had to include a measure of psychological characteristic (personality or self-efficacy), an external measure of teaching effectiveness (student achievement or observed teaching performance), and sufficient data to calculate effect sizes.

Results. Our search returned 117 articles, reduced after careful reading to 40 studies: 10 linking personality with teaching effectiveness and 30 linking self-efficacy with teaching effectiveness (studies included >6000 teachers). The overall effect size between teacher personality and teaching effectiveness was r = .01, p = .74, CI = -.051 to .073, equivalent to Cohen’s d = .02 (non-significant). The overall effect size between self-efficacy and teaching effectiveness was r = .17, p < .01, CI = .10 to .24, equivalent to Cohen’s d = .34 (small). A further breakdown showed that the effect size between self-efficacy and observed teaching performance was r = .29, p < .01, CI = .23 to .34, equivalent to Cohen’s d = .58 (medium).

Discussion. Teacher personality showed a non-significant relationship with teaching effectiveness; teacher self-efficacy showed a robust relationship. The relationship between personality and teaching effectiveness may be obscured by (a) the lack of correspondence between predictor and outcome, (b) the absence of an actual relationship (psychological predictors weaken for tasks of high complexity), or (c) flaws with conventional personality measures.
Stable qualities—such as personality—may not be as important for effective teaching as more dynamic motivation factors such as self-efficacy. The findings raise important questions about the kinds of psychological characteristics that are critical for effective teaching. For example, in the UK, the Department of Education has recently (2012) mandated assessment of non-cognitive (i.e., personality) attributes for selection of teacher trainees. Examining the relationship between teachers’ psychological characteristics and measures of teaching effectiveness may prove useful for identifying effective teachers, but our findings suggest that policy-makers and practitioners may overstate the importance of teachers’ personality in teacher selection. For practicing teachers, interventions targeting the sources of self-efficacy may increase effectiveness in the classroom.

Authors