Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Descriptor
Search Tips
Annual Meeting Theme
Exhibitors
About Philadelphia
About AERA
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Purpose. McLaughlin and Talbert (2006) argue that to be effective, teachers need to re-conceptualize learning and to develop fundamentally new forms of instruction. They contend that such challenges require opportunities for “teacher professionalism that embraces new norms and expectations for student learning” (p. 2). Teacher learning communities (TLCs) offer one approach to increasing teacher professionalism and commitment. TLCs can be effective partly because they help counter some forms of teacher culture which are detrimental to teacher effectiveness. These include privacy (vs. collaboration), individual autonomy (vs. collective autonomy/responsibility), egalitarianism (vs. recognized expertise), and present-orientation (vs. reflection). TLCs can be motivating for teachers because they addressteacher’s own concerns (e.g., instruction) and offer sustained support from peers to improve practice.
I examine the development and outcomes of four TLCs during a 3-year intervention in one school. Teacher leaders, selected by peers, facilitated the TLCs, which focused on principles and instructional strategies to foster student engagement.
Perspective. The perspective is developmental and situative, with a focus on how teacher leaders’ goals developed as a function of leader-group interaction, the school culture, and the intervention context.
Methods/Data sources. Teacher leaders of each TLC were interviewed 4 times a year for 3 consecutive years about their goals, role, strategies, self-evaluations, and views of colleagues. Interviews were transcribed and coded within interview categories. Codes formed six themes: leader role, goals and foci of TLCs, influences of teacher culture and obstacles, and outcomes.
Results. In year 1 (y1), most leaders expressed low efficacy* and uncertainty about their role* and TLC goals* possibly because the role was new and may have signaled unequal status. Some teacher members viewed goals to improve instruction as eroding individual autonomy (“It felt like work to get people to talk”), but by the end of y1, leaders believed that they had developed strategies* to increase TLC group engagement, such as “ask people to come with something more specific to contribute,” and efficacy increased.
Because TLC goals of collaboration, reflection and deprivatizing practice challenged teacher culture, leaders’ goals in y1emphasized building relationships of trust*, increasing group ownership*, and fostering engagement* and interaction*. These goals decreased by y3 because leaders had succeeded in building communities.
An impediment to focusing on improving instruction was administrative pressure to raise test scores, which prompted an increased focus on data/testing* in y2/3 (“we haven’t even talked because we’ve got this [test] coming up … and we’ve all been thinking about that”). By y3 leaders were more comfortable challenging the culture* (“…we have to have higher expectations”; [we need] “a deeper level of reflection”).
Outcomes included leaders’ increased perceptions of progress*, such as continuing use of strategies to foster engagement*, while meeting PLC goals* for reflection* and greater collaboration*.
Significance. “The literature … offers little guidance on the change process … entailed in changing professional culture …” (Talbert, 2009, p. 556). This developmental study contributes to this literature by identifying motivational affordances and constraints for TLCs and illustrates the complexity of teacher motivation and instructional change.
* indicates a final code