Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Descriptor
Search Tips
Annual Meeting Theme
Exhibitors
About Philadelphia
About AERA
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
In this paper, we extend the use of Halagao et. al’s (2009) Critical Framework of Review to cross-evaluate two types of curricula that aim to reach a multicultural population of teachers and students in California and Hawaii.
In California, we use the Critical Framework of Review to study San Francisco Unified School Districts’ (SFUSD) ethnic studies curriculum that is geared toward 9th graders. This study examines the curricular components and pedagogical approaches of the Ethnic Studies in SFUSD intervention and its possible impact on academic, civic and community engagement. It has three curricular components: 1) Critical Consciousness: unpacking and analyzing identity formation, stereotypes, and racism; 2) Historical Connection: recovering histories, contributions, and social movements of marginalized peoples and connecting them to the students’ family and community experiences; 3) Civic Agency and Community Action: presenting opportunities for youth to participate in action research that tackles challenges facing their schools and communities.
These curricular components are delivered through culturally and community responsive pedagogical approaches that privilege problem-posing inquiry groups, dialogue, and community engagement (Tintiangco-Cubales, Daus-Magbual & Daus-Magbual, 2010), which have been shown to be instrumental in developing a student’s civic identity (Kahne & Middaugh, 2008; Rubin & Hayes, 2010). Through academically rigorous assignments, like Youth Participatory Action Research, students analyze real-life issues to positively transform their lives and communities.
In Hawaii, we use the Critical Framework of Review to evaluate a STEM and culture-based professional development curriculum, A`o Hawaiʻi: Viewing the Classroom as a Canoe; Viewing the Canoe as a Classroom. Inspired by Hawaii’s voyaging canoes, Hōkūle‘a and Hikianalia, Worldwide Voyage mission to mālama (care for) Island Earth - our natural environment, children and all humankind, A'o Hawaii is an educational movement that aims to transform the structure, function, and purpose of schools. In Hawaiian, A'o means to "teach and learn" in a reciprocal relationship. We are both teacher and learner and “Aʻo Hawaiʻi is the teaching and learning of our place and connection to others.
A’o Hawaii is a collaboration of culture-based organizations, higher education, and a diverse group of educators from across the Hawaiian Islands. Using a critical and cultural theoretical lens (Freire, 1974; Gay, 2010) this study examines A`o Hawaii’s mission to re-empower educators and youth to embrace teaching and learning as a dynamic process that draws on indigenous knowledge and values infused with the development of 21st Century skills. It evaluates the potential impact of the crew of teachers and students to navigate educational transformation and towards a sustainable destination for all.
By applying the Critical Framework of Review on these two curricula, we examine how the tool serves to decolonize evaluation methodologies. What did we learn about our curriculum and the Critical Framework? What conclusions did we reach as a result of applying it to two different curricula? What adaptations and challenges did we encounter in using the framework? This comparative study has implications for both “taking back” evaluation and stretching our understanding of curriculum, policy, and practice within a critical, cultural and community responsive context.
Patricia E. Halagao, University of Hawaii - Manoa
Allyson Tintiangco-Cubales, San Francisco State University
Maharaj Desai, University of Hawaii - Manoa