Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Educating for Futures in Power-Marginalized Regions: A Sociological Framework for Rethinking and Researching Aspirations

Sun, April 6, 2:15 to 3:45pm, Convention Center, Floor: 100 Level, 120C

Abstract

Objectives
This paper critiques the deficit and individualist-psychological assumptions coded in ‘aspirations’ discourse within Australian educational policies. The paper then develops a conceptual framework for robust sociological appreciation of how power-marginalized young people—situated in school, family, local community and wider historic-structural contexts—form hopes and strategies towards possible futures. Joining literatures and data, the paper theorizes how young people’s subjective formations mix three analytically distinct modes of aspiring: ‘doxic,’ ‘habituated’ and ‘emergent’ (see below), deriving from different social-cultural grounds. Finally, the paper suggests a methodological approach to research the complexity of aspiration-formations.

Theoretical framework
Concepts of ‘doxic’ and ‘habituated’ aspirations draw on Bourdieu’s conceptual tools (1990, 1992) for appreciating (a) the normative power of populist discourses to shape ‘commonsense’, or doxa, which relate to hopes/strategies towards futures; and (b) how certain subjective dispositions form as deep ‘second natures’, or habitus, through early-life immersion in family/community practices and relations, tending towards certain future self-investments. The concept of ‘emergent’ aspirations draws on Williams’ (1977) discussion of ‘emergent structures of feeling’ among younger generations who read the world anew but at incipient, pre-verbal levels of sense. In developing methodological ways to draw emergent sense into voice and pro-action—to capacitate emergent aspirations—the paper draws on (a) the Funds of Knowledge approach (Gonzales et al. 2005) for building curriculum around knowledge assets in family/community sites beyond school; and (b) Appadurai’s (2004) view of aspirations as social-cultural potentials that gain capacity in communicating around pro-actions to meet needs.

Methods, techniques, modes of inquiry
Policy sociology (Ball 1994) informs critique of policy discourses on ‘aspiration. In theorizing ‘doxic’, ‘habituated’ and ‘emergent’ modes of aspiring, illustrative data comes from (a) interviews with students/parents, and (b) ethnographic engagement with an art teacher’s classroom (see below).

Data
Interviews with secondary students and parents comprised a family case studies (FCS) project (2010) in the urban-fringe suburbs of an Australian capital city. Interviews asked about family/community funds of knowledge, and about aspirations and educational strategies towards futures. The art teacher’s classroom was engaged within a major research project (ARC1, 2004-2007) in the same suburbs; data for this paper involves students creating clay animation stories highlighting local community conditions of concern and imagining community actions to change them.

Results and/or warranted arguments
FCS interview data, combined with conceptual tools from Bourdieu, both illustrate and support theorization of ‘doxic’ and ‘habituated’ modes of aspiring. ARC1 data, combined with conceptual tools from Williams, Appadurai, and Funds of Knowledge literature, illustrate and support theorization of the ‘emergent’ mode of aspiring.

Significance
Building on data, analysis and theoretical labor, this paper pioneers a framework for in-depth research and analysis of student/family aspirations towards futures. Minimal research on aspirations to date, mostly linked to policies, has been narrow and short-term in focus, and not sociologically robust (Sellar, Gale & Parker 2011). This paper’s critique of policy assumptions, and innovative conceptual and methodological developments, can support future research, policy and educational practice that grasps the complex social-cultural grounds and logics constituting aspirations.

Authors