Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Descriptor
Search Tips
Annual Meeting Theme
Exhibitors
About Philadelphia
About AERA
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Purpose
The adoption of the Common Core State Standards (CCSS) raises both opportunities and challenges, particularly for educators of young children. While the CCSS in literacy set forth worthy expectations for our nation’s youth to achieve at the completion of their high school years - demonstration of critical thinking, higher-order skills of synthesis and analysis, the ability to tackle and comprehend complex texts in a variety of genres, and application of knowledge to real-life problems – many educators feel that the way in which the standards have been backwards-mapped from high school graduation to the youngest grades does not take into consideration how young children learn: that they progress at different paces, in different ways, and frequently in a non-linear manner. This mismatch between expectations and developmental readiness is also reflected in the performance assessments that are another positive consequence of the advent of the CCSS: While performance assessment allows for a richer demonstration of higher order skills, the standards’ (and the assessments’ of these standards) grade by grade expectations do not adequately take into consideration the natural developmental variation of young children’s growth and development across different domains and, as a result, may not always adequately allow children to demonstrate what they know and can do in the ways that they learn.
This paper reports on how these tensions manifested in a district initiative to engage teachers in the development of performance assessments for students in the early childhood years (K-2) tied to the CCSS in literacy.
Mode of Inquiry and Data Sources
This reflective inquiry was conducted through participant-observation by a facilitator with expertise in early childhood and performance assessment who worked with teachers in the project examined. Data sources include field notes from the project, review of the assessments and documents created by the project, feedback elicited from teachers, as well as author reflections.
Findings
This study raised issues and insights pertaining to assessment quality:
- Does assessing reading development through a writing task confound two different abilities that develop in different ways and at different rates in young children?
- Do grade-level standards-based rubrics take into consideration the natural developmental variation of young children?
- Does a writing task provide teachers with instructionally useful information about young children’s development in reading?
It also raised issues and insights pertaining to the process of developing assessments and scoring them:
- Do teachers have sufficient knowledge about literacy development and sufficient assessment literacy skills to design instructionally-useful and developmentally-appropriate assessments?
- Can an assessment designed for accountability purposes (teacher evaluation) also be instructionally useful?
- Can teachers assess their own students’ progress in sufficiently reliable and valid ways so that a classroom-based and teacher-scored assessment can be used for accountability purposes?
Significance
The questions and insights raised by this study have important implications for the development of instructionally useful literacy assessments for young children and the possibility of using teacher-designed, classroom-based, performance assessments in accountability systems.