Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

How Teachers’ Epistemologies Shape Teacher-Student Conferences About Argumentative Writing

Sat, April 5, 10:35am to 12:05pm, Marriott, Floor: Fourth Level, Franklin 6

Abstract

Objective

Although the Common Core State Standards (CCSS) for argumentative writing call for “integrat(ing) information into the text selectively” (p. 46), several of the 33 English language arts (ELA) teachers we observed over two years (2010-2012) displayed a deeper and more nuanced range of approaches to teaching argumentative writing that was made manifest during teacher-student writing conferences. In addition to essay form (structural-textual), some of the ELA teachers were also concerned about rhetorical contexts (social practices) or about the development and authorizing of ideas (ideational).

Theoretical Framework

A focus on the social and cultural contexts of composing written arguments considers written language as a social and cultural construction (Bakhtin, 1981; Vygotsky, 1987). From this perspective, writing is understood as language in context, reflecting writers’ mediations in the social world, including the ELA classroom. From this perspective, the teacher is a particular and situated reader with her own epistemologies grounded in classroom experience. Moreover, the social context of a classroom and the experiences of individual students also shape the writing conference in ways that are nuanced and contextualized (Sperling, 1998).

Methods

Given that teachers develop argumentative epistemologies that differ in terms of beliefs about argumentation and approaches to teaching writing, how do teachers and students accomplish a one-to-one conversation in support of students' learning argumentative writing?

Data Collection and Data Analysis

We observed three ELA teachers, recommended for their reputations as excellent writing teachers, during instructional units leading to their students’ completing teacher-sponsored argumentative essays. We observed teacher-student conferences, along with the other classroom activities, and all of this was digitally recorded for later analysis, supplemented by extensive field notes that recorded classroom activities along with observer commentary. The primary data for this study are audiotapes and videotapes of the teacher-student writing conferences for six students (two students [successful and less successful] in each classroom).

We employed a microethnographic approach to discourse analysis (Bloome, et al., 2005) analyzing each message unit (Green & Wallat, 1981) with regard to how it builds upon previous utterances, implies social relations among people including the reader and the author, indexes particular forms of logic, shifts between the topics and the structure of an argument, and links to various social contexts at multiple levels.

Findings and Significance

This study makes manifest contrasting ways of writing, thinking, and arguing that teachers with differing argumentative epistemologies offered and that, at times, their students appropriated during conferencing about argumentative writing. The writing conferences allow us to look more closely at what we observed during classroom instruction. First, the teachers’ argumentative epistemologies were more explicit due to the conferences’ focused and sustained nature. Second, the students’ appropriation of or resistance to the epistemologies was evident during the conferences with students who were more able and willing to articulate uncertainty. Finally, the teachers did not adhere to a particular epistemology as they shifted their foci to students’ concerns, confusions, and rhetorical entanglements.

Authors