Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Descriptor
Search Tips
Annual Meeting Theme
Exhibitors
About Philadelphia
About AERA
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
In this paper, the authors argue for critical language scholars to re-mediate (Cole & Griffin, 1982; Gutierrez, Morales & Martinez, 2009) research for the purpose of providing non-dominant communities with humanizing, transformative outcomes. Authors draw on their own empirical research with Black and Latina/o high school youth in an English Language Arts classroom setting in the west coast (Author 1) and with children of immigrants in an elementary after school program in the east coast (Author 2) to explore how Linguistic Anthropological (LA) tools can be used to transform learning. This paper specifically speaks to educational research that is informed by language ideology research (Kroskrity, 2000) and conversational narrative research (Ochs & Capps, 2001).
Early LA research expanded what counted as language and literacy among non-dominant children and youth in classroom settings (Cazden, John-Steiner & Hymes, 1985). Consequent work directly transformed teaching practices in ways that leveraged non-dominant students’ cultural and linguistic repertoires of practice (Au, 1980; Phillips, 1983, Michaels, 1981). While educational researchers continue to draw from LA tools to highlight teaching/learning interactions in situ, the authors will argue for a re-mediating of LA research tools in formal and informal learning settings to engage in activist and/or advocacy research that promotes transformative practices for and with non-dominant children and youth.
Too often, educational researchers employing LA tools in educational settings have attempted to be critical without addressing the question “Critical for whom?” (Souto-Manning, 2013). By not addressing this question, educational researchers paradigmatically position non-dominant children and youth within a deficits paradigm (Carter & Goodwin, 1994), embrace an ideology of pathology, and ultimately colonize participants—ethnocentrically imposing their own understandings, assumptions, and experiences upon them (Sumner, 1906). In engaging in research that is critical, it is important to look closely and listen carefully in order to understand the perspectives and experiences of participants in their own terms rather than superimposing our own perspectives of what is problematic and needs to be transformed. In this paper, we recognize the need for educational researchers employing LA tools to move away from such ethnocentric positionings. We thus look closely and listen carefully to the actions and interactions, to the co-constructed conversational narratives (Ochs & Capps, 2001), of children and youth from non-dominant backgrounds in classrooms and schools. We theorize from practice (González, Moll, & Amanti, 2004).
To counter this paradigm we offer an approach to LA research in educational settings that draws on cultural historical theoretical perspectives, particularly the notion of re-mediation offered by Cole & Griffin (1982). Their work argued against reductive educational practices that treated the learner as needing “remediating.” Instead, they re-mediated learning environments, seeking to saturate learning environments with robust culturally and linguistically meaningful tools. In this spirit, the authors argue that we must re-mediate the research environments and the tools afforded to us from the Linguistic Anthropological tradition. That is, we must reorganize our research in ways that allow our data to inform activist positions and advocacy for non-dominant and fragile youth in learning contexts.
Danny C. Martinez, University of California - Davis
Mariana Souto-Manning, Teachers College, Columbia University