Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Descriptor
Search Tips
Annual Meeting Theme
Exhibitors
About Philadelphia
About AERA
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
The literature on young children’s multimodal literacies has highlighted the ways children tap the semiotic landscape to navigate and transform school literacy curricula (Author 1, 2011; Author 5, 2009; Dyson, 2003). Play has been central to this line of work, and one perspective on play in early literacy defines it as critical transformation Guss (2005)—a space for children to take control and question practices, speak for themselves, and transform and redefine themselves. As such, play can be innovative and subversive (Guss, 2005), emerging as “a ‘counter-practice’ (Campano & Simon, 2010) that disrupts the rigidity of standardization and accountability that has trickled down to early childhood classrooms” (Ghiso, 2013, p. 31).
This paper examines the way two focal children in a public kindergarten classroom deployed multimodal literacies to engage in play as “counter-practice,” thus showing signs of emerging critical agency. The events examined in this paper were drawn from a year-long ethnographic inquiry of a mandated balanced literacy curriculum in a kindergarten classroom where digital and print-based literacies intersected. Data were collected two mornings a week over a nine-month period (October 2003-June 2004) through participant observation in the morning literacy block, supplemented by artifact collection and conversations with the teacher. Classroom literacy events were documented in fieldnotes, selected events in which the two focal students (Jewel and Hector) participated were videotaped and transcribed for analysis, and artifacts were photocopied. The analysis draws on poststructuralist theory to understand how school normalized particular meanings of literacy, and how the children positioned themselves in relation to one another and to broader systems of knowledge (Davies & Harré, 1990; Foucault, 1977). Semiotic theories (Author 5, 1984, 2006; Kress, 2003) provide analytic tools for examining how children’s sign-making, especially their transmediation (moving across sign systems), transformed the school literacy space that exercised disciplinary power over their literacies and bodies.
The findings suggest that the focal children engaged in sign-making that challenged and sometimes mocked school literacy practices. For example, Hector, who was recognized as a “successful” reader and writer, read his “little book” with the intonation of a robot during partner reading or chanted the spelling of his partner’s name during computer lab just as they were expected to do in morning meeting. At other times, he moved fluently between the print literacy that marked him as successful and the images, sounds, and movements of his play. Jewel, who had acquired the label “struggling” reader/writer, engaged in solitary play; in writer’s workshop she filled her writing paper with intricate drawings and in the computer lab she continually erased and even used the “bomb” to clear her screen, both of which were forbidden. Both children managed to deploy their favored semiotic resources and practices to take control and speak for themselves, without saying a word. The pleasure they appeared to take in subverting school literacy, even if that subjected them to discipline (more often for Jewel than Hector) signified an emerging critical agency that could be tapped for curricular innovations.