Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Educational Goods and Charter Schools

Sat, April 5, 2:45 to 4:15pm, Convention Center, Floor: 100 Level, 115B

Abstract

An important policy debate in the US concerns charter schools. The interesting question, from our perspective, is not whether charter schools, on average, outperform regular public schools; but on what considerations should inform decisions by states about how to design charter legislation (or whether to reject it) and decisions on the more local level about whether to grant a charter in a particular area or city. One kind of charter schools – the “high commitment” model, exemplified by KIPP schools – is of particular interest, because such schools target disadvantaged children, and thus aim to contribute to equity. Much of the research on KIPP and similar schools looks at test scores – which measure valuable educational experiences very imperfectly to say the least – and most of it neglects the impact such schools have on the other schools that surround them. The evidence is not clear; but if the schools do not provide benefits then decisions about them are (morally) easy. And if they both benefit the students and have a positive impact on surrounding schools then the decisions are, again, easy. But there are reasons to suspect that the schools benefit some of their students, at the expense of other disadvantaged children. From the perspective of equity, it is not clear whether this can be justified or not, because conceptions of equity tend to be clear about redistribution between the advantaged and disadvantaged, but not among the advantaged or disadvantaged. We explore some more refined conceptions of equity and how they interact with different interpretations of the evidence to support different policy choices.

Author