Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Descriptor
Search Tips
Annual Meeting Theme
Exhibitors
About Philadelphia
About AERA
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Objective
The aim of this paper is to present an identity-based conceptual framework of students’ perceived relevance. After presenting the conceptual model, we will present findings demonstrating how the model depicts differences in perceived relevance constructions of biology content among junior high school students of different genders and with different profiles of science-related expectancy and values.
Theoretical Perspective
This investigation utilized an emerging identity-based model of relevance that conceptualizes it as comprised of three components: (1) the contextual target—the content or environmental stimuli perceived as relevant (e.g., “photosynthesis”); (2) the identity target—the self-aspect connected to the content (e.g., “career goals”); and (3) the relevance lens—the cognitive-affective connection between the contextual and identity targets (e.g., “utility value”). This conceptualization incorporates into relevance other motivational constructs, including interest and personal goals. In the current study, perceived relevance is investigated particularly in relation to Eccles’ expectancy-value perspective (Eccles & Wigfield, 2002), with the goal to investigate the relevance constructions of students with different motivational profiles.
Methods/Data Sources
One-hundred forty 9th grade biology students (86 girls, 54 boys) from a Northeastern US suburban school, who took part in a larger, multi-phase, mixed-methods study that investigated perceived relevance in science, were administered a survey assessing science domain expectancy and values (Eccles & Wigfield, 1995) and a separate survey on science-content-specific relevance perceptions. The latter instrument was constructed using qualitative data on students’ constructions of relevance. Students were evaluated following a unit on Mendelian genetics.
Results
Cluster analysis identified three groups: high, average, and mixed science expectancy-value profiles. Separate MDS analyses of the three groups indicated a replicated general structural feature of relevance constructions: (1) a contextual target area that serves as an anchor in the output maps; (2) a dimension of proximity to the contextual target area that can indicate relative perceived relevance of various identity-target items. The map of the group with high expectancy and value manifested many identity target and relevance lens items in close proximity to the contextual target area. In comparison, the maps of both the average and mixed expectancy-value groups had the identity target items related to the student’s body, health, and family closest to the contextual target area, with other identity target items much further away. MDS of the two gender groups demonstrated that females had interest-related items closest to the contextual area while males had items related to the student’s body, health, and family more proximal.
Significance
The findings support a conceptual approach of perceived relevance as multidimensional, identity-based, contextual, and tightly integrated with other motivational constructs. The findings also imply that individual differences in domain-general motivational constructs have a substantial relationship with the contextual experience of relevance. Existing expectancy and value for a domain seem to be a vital bridge to deep context-specific relevance experiences. The model and instrument have the potential to provide practitioners with insights into their students’ contextual perceived relevance and serve as a guide for investigating the effect of interventions to promote relevance and evaluate its relations with student engagement.