Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

(Counter)narrating the Curriculum: A Survey of California High School Ethnic Studies Courses

Mon, April 7, 8:15 to 9:45am, Convention Center, Floor: Terrace Level, Terrace IV

Abstract

California’s most recent demographic shift to a non-White majority has fundamentally changed the composition of the school-aged populations and carries major implications for K-12 curriculum and teaching. This qualitative case study (Dyson & Genishi, 2005) reports on the proliferation of Ethnic Studies (ES) courses and teachers in the state of California. One of the overarching research questions guiding this study is: How are college preparatory ES courses being conceptualized, created, and implemented?
Rooted in critical curriculum studies, this paper is informed by Au’s (2012) concept of curricular standpoint (CS), which recognizes the dialectical relationship between the subjectivity of experience and the materiality of social and economic relations. The unequal distribution of power in society leads to the unequal distribution of curricular knowledge in schools. This calls for a revitalization of curriculum studies as a critical intervening force in the struggle against not only the cultural dehumanization in our schools, but also in the persistent structural and material inequalities. Within a CS framework, the development of “oppositional consciousness” (Sandoval, 2000) is necessary as the historically dominated create transformative epistemologies and curricula as part of their struggle against existing power relations.
The participants in this study consist of fourteen high school teachers with two or more years of experience teaching college preparatory ES courses, and represent seven different public school districts across California. Nine of the participants are males and five are females. In-depth semi-structured interviews were recorded and analyzed, and curriculum maps, unit plans, and course syllabi were collected for content document analysis. In analyzing these documents, I employed critical discourse analysis (Fairclough, 1995) to generate a grounded theory (Glaser & Strauss, 1967).
Despite the current context of a broader neoliberal education agenda, all fourteen educators, with the support and trust of their schools, administrators, and community leaders, had a free hand in piloting innovative, rigorous, and culturally responsive curriculum. This paper reports on the ways in which ES courses are currently being offered, by whom, and by what means. Furthermore, this study also elucidates teacher nuances as they pertain to their understandings of curriculum as inquiry, curriculum theorizing, pedagogical philosophies, and their general experiences of developing curriculum in isolation even with some administrative and community support.
ES, along with its United States civil rights movement lineage, also finds its origins in the Third World and its ambitious project of fundamentally altering the course of world history. Thus, I start with a California survey as it is the birthplace of the interdisciplinary field of ES and carries more than forty-five-years of grassroots activism and organizing for the liberation of Third World and colonized peoples. Given the lacuna of literature on high school ES curriculum and teaching, this study serves as an initial database for subsequent comparative research and theory building around ES curriculum and teaching at the secondary level. Furthermore, as the demographic landscape of California continues to shift, this paper concludes with a call for the reconceptualization of 21st century social studies teacher education.

Author