Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Integrated STEM and the Development of Deeper Learning Skills

Sat, April 5, 2:45 to 4:15pm, Marriott, Floor: Fourth Level, Franklin 5

Abstract

Objectives or purposes
Successfully motivating STEM integration in K-12 education depends in part on other trends in the current landscape. Chief among these are the newest generation of discipline-based standards in mathematics (CCSSI, 2010) and in science and engineering (NRC, 2012), as well as recent calls for supporting “deeper learning” and 21st Century skills. This paper will examine some ways in which integrated STEM education meshes with these other initiatives but also some potential challenges.

Perspectives or theoretical framework
This presentation follows a framework developed in the recent NRC report titled Education for Life and Work: Transferable Knowledge and Skills in the 21st Century (NRC, 2012), which examined evidence related to recent calls to cultivate “deeper learning” and to better prepare K-12 students in “21st Century Skills,” such as problem solving, critical thinking, communication, and collaboration. The report approached deeper learning from the point of view of transferable knowledge that can be used to understand new situations and can be applied in meaningful ways. It classified competencies into three intertwined domains of cognitive, interpersonal, and intrapersonal skills.

Methods and Sources of Evidence
The NRC report examined evidence from a variety of research literatures to evaluate the importance of various competencies for long-term outcomes; to evaluate the alignment of these competencies with the learning goals and standards of specific academic disciplines; and to evaluate what is known about how to promote deeper learning and 21st Century competencies in educational settings.

Results and Conclusions
(1) Current mathematics and science standards have some significant areas of overlap that provide fertile ground for integrated STEM education, such as incorporating mathematical concepts like scale and proportion in science, and developing fluency with computational thinking and modeling.
(2) However, an analysis of standards as well as discipline-based research literatures also reveals goals and concepts that are unique to particular disciplines or divergently defined across disciplines. Science and engineering, for example, share a variety of important practices but also have important differences in terms of goals and criteria for success. Integrated approaches need to be mindful of these differences.
(3) Studies of transfer and generalization of knowledge indicate that it is often domain-specific and dependent on well-developed and fluidly interconnected knowledge bases within a discipline (Mayer, 2010). However, STEM integration, unless done carefully, may be unbalanced in the degree to which it supports the development of fundamental disciplinary knowledge in all of the participating disciplines.
(4) Although the evidence base is still evolving, project-based learning, which is often featured in integrated STEM initiatives, provides a promising approach in K-12 education (Giijbels et al, 2005; Strobel & van Barneveld (2009), and may provide good opportunities for incorporating some of the non-cognitive competencies that have been found to be important for long-term success.

Scientific or scholarly significance of the work
Integrated STEM education has potential to improve a variety of student outcomes but would require significant investments. Potential risks, benefits, and opportunities for synergies with other initiatives should be evaluated in the light of available evidence.

Author