Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Peer Academic and Social Reputations as Predictors for Change in School Engagement

Mon, April 7, 2:15 to 3:45pm, Convention Center, Floor: 100 Level, 103B

Abstract

School engagement is a complex and reciprocal process of emotions and behaviors within the individual that are partly determined by children’s competence beliefs and social dynamics in the classroom (Skinner et al., 2008). Positive reinforcement from the classroom environment is theorized to influence competence beliefs and desire to engage in academic tasks (Harter, 1981; Weiner, 1985). Peers affiliation patterns can influence student engagement in elementary classrooms (Kindermann, 1993; 2007), but reputations that children develop with classmates represent another form of peer feedback. For example, as students acquire a reputation as poor in academics, peers begin to ignore their academic input during group work (Cohen, 1997); not surprisingly, peer academic reputations (PAR) predict changes in academic self-concept and effort (Gest et al., 2005, 2008). Similarly, supportive social relationships with peers can positively influence academic interest and engagement (Wentzel, 1998), whereas children who face peer rejection risk disengagement from school (Bierman, 2004).
The present study examined influences of two forms peer feedback -- peer academic reputation (PAR) and peer social preference -- on within-year changes in three measures of school engagement. Changes in academic and social self-concept were tested as domain-specific meditators of the relationships between peer feedback and school engagement. This study expands on previous reports (Gest et al., 2005, 2008) by including two student-reported dimensions of academic engagement and by exploring the joint influences of two types of peer reputation across three elementary school grades.
The sample consisted of 1523 students from 96 1st, 3rd and 5th grade classrooms. PAR was created by subtracting two negative nomination items from two positive items (Gest et al., 2008), while social preference was calculated by subtracting ‘like-least’ from ‘like-most’ nominations (Coie et al.,1982). Five items were combined to create a scale of teacher-rated effort. Students rated their own academic effort and valuing of school (Striving, 8-items, alpha = .72) and their affective orientation to school (Affect, 8 items, alpha = .86). Academic and social self-concept were measured with Harter’s (1982) scales.
Multilevel Linear Modeling (MLM) was used to test the effect of peer feedback during the fall on fall-to-spring changes in engagement measures. Consistent with previous research, peer academic reputation in the fall significantly predicted changes in both teacher-ratings of Effort and student self-reports of Striving in school. Academic self-concept partially mediated these associations and provided a weak but significant indirect pathway between PAR and Affect. Peer social preference was significantly related to changes in Effort and Striving, with a significant indirect pathway to Striving through its relationship to changes in social self-concept.
As expected, first-graders were significantly higher in both Striving and Affect, and all grades experienced similar within-year declines in engagement. PAR was more predictive of changes in teacher-rated effort for first-graders, perhaps reflecting that academic reputation is more strongly tied to student effort in earlier grades. Social preference was significantly more predictive of changes in social self-concept for fifth-graders, suggesting that older children base more of their self-evaluation on their social reputation.

Authors