Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Looking Down: Why TV Won't Let Gay Men "Grow Up"

Fri, April 17, 8:15 to 9:45am, Swissotel, Floor: Event Centre Second Level, Montreux 3

Abstract

This paper explores how gay characters on a recent American television show are situated to occupy a child-like position that is always already learning to “be” gay. Focusing on the character Patrick from HBO’s Looking, the analysis centers on the ways this adult-aged character serves as an introduction-of-sorts to gay culture for the audience. That is, the character is used as a plot device for the audience to learn, alongside and with the character, what it means to be a gay man. This paper, then, asks why, in a highly anticipated, gay-themed and gay-created show, must a gay character be rendered as a neophyte (in relation to his gayness) so that the audience can safely and voyeuristically get to know how being “gay” works?
Pulling from theorizing on the image of the child and notions of futurity (Edelman, 2009; Kincaid, 2004; Mayo, 2006; Muñoz, 2009; Stockton, 2009), this paper places under examination the social constructs constituting dominant notions and understandings of “child”. Furthermore, I suggest gay characters on television, regardless of age, serve as a tool with which the (supposedly straight) audience learns about gay people, lives, and cultures. This positioning results from dominant understandings concerning the viewing “public/s” (Warner, 2002) and how those shows perceive of they address their intended audiences (Ellsworth, 1997).
This paper borrows from Halperin’s (2012) project of seeking to “understand how [gay] counter-acculturation operates, the exact logic by which gay male subjects resist the summons to experience the world in heterosexual and hetero-normative ways” (p. 7, emphasis is original). I explore how Patrick experiences in Looking exemplify this process of counter-acculturation while he serves as the audience’s proxy in the task of learning “how to be gay”. Through visual culture methodologies (Duncum, 2012; Halberstam, 2002; Rogoff, 2002), I examine Patrick’s experience during the show’s first season to elucidate how his adult body is portrayed as child-like in relation to his own gayness. These methodologies are key towards the excavation of the social, political, and discursive constructions of the images of gay bodies in popular culture as always already foreign and in need of translation.
The analysis of Patrick (as the gay-adult-as-child-learning-to-be-gay) suggests that the viewing “public” is always already conceived of as straight and without knowledge of gayness. Patrick, despite being described as a decade-long openly gay resident of San Francisco, is depicted learning about being gay for the instructional benefit of the audience. His (and the audience’s) coming of age/gayness is a pedagogical tool that educates the public about what gayness “is”. With Patrick’s storyline in mind, this paper pushes back against the possibility of gay representation as being “authentic” and, instead, firmly centers on asking after what these portrayals do towards reproducing normative, ingrained notions of youth, sexuality, and gender and how one comes to know what it means to be gay. Moreover, it offers new tools to reframe discussions concerning representation of gay subjects in the media today.

Author