Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Etiology of Real Girlhood: Trans Childhoods in the Media

Fri, April 17, 8:15 to 9:45am, Swissotel, Floor: Event Centre Second Level, Montreux 3

Abstract

Representations of out trans people in the mainstream media are on the rise. From powerhouse actress and Emmy-nominee Laverne Cox and the media empire of Janet Mock to the viral story of trans teen models Katie Hill and Arin Andrews, these representations increasingly reflect a sympathetic view of trans individuals. Yet this increased attention on trans people and issues of trans inclusion brings an attendant increase in mainstream meaning-making around trans experiences. This paper explores the ways in which media representations of trans children have contended with medial and juridical narratives about trans identity, producing narratives about what constitutes an authentic – and worthy – trans childhood.
Dean Spade (2006) has argued that a singular “trans childhood” narrative detailing consistently cross-gendered behavior from a very young age became all but compulsory for individuals seeking gender confirming procedures in the twentieth century. In this paper, I examine transcripts of mainstream news media appearances by two white, normatively feminine trans children and their families, using critical discourse analysis to attempt to understand what stories they are telling – and what stories are being told about them. Most notably, the data show that the children are rarely permitted to speak for themselves in media appearances; rather, their stories are framed by their parents, as Tey Meadows (2011) has argued, as well as by interviewers, visual editing, and other elements of production. In fact, the visual is critically important here: the most significant way that trans children “speak” is through their appearance. Their performance of normatively feminine gender expression becomes the most important element of sympathetic media coverage, because it affirms the naturalness of their – and, as Judith Butler (2001) has argued, our – gender.
Ultimately, I argue that in these representations, trans childhood is taken up as a proof of "real" trans identity, rather than as a retrospectively-constructed narrative used to frame appeals for medical or legal transition. In this way, the trans childhood becomes a purportedly authentic lived and embodied experience common to all trans-identified young people. The implications of this tendency for education, as I see them, are threefold: 1) it renders some children and adolescents invisible because their genderqueerness is not an acknowledged trans experience; 2) it renders others invisible because they are brown, poor, urban, or adolescent and trans; and 3) it runs counter to attempts to create greater gender equity in schools and to destabilize strict binary gendering in school activities, curricula, programming, and spaces. As representations of trans children in the media proliferate, it continues to be important for educators to critically examine media representations that reinforce binary conceptions of gender, and especially to interrogate narratives that suggest that all trans children have similar experiences or perform gender in the same narrow spectrum of ways. Further, school and district policy should reflect a willingness to flexibly identify and support gender nonconforming young people, rather than relying on rigid taxonomies to determine when to provide accommodations to trans children.

Author