Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Can a Case-Based, Online Learning Environment Prompt Positive Change in Preservice Teachers' Knowledge and Dispositions for Parent–Teacher Communication?

Sun, April 19, 12:25 to 1:55pm, Swissotel, Floor: Event Centre Second Level, Montreux 3

Abstract

1) Objectives/Background

Parent-teacher communication (PTC) is an essential but invisible practice that most new teachers only experience upon entering the profession. Drawing from observational learning theory’s (Bandura, 1999) assumption that watching others succeed and fail is an efficient way to learn, this study tested whether an online case-based environment—including opportunities for making decisions, observing contrasting models of practice, and receiving feedback—could enhance teacher candidates‘ knowledge of effective PTC strategies. This work is important because if its approach is successful, the FSCP SIG community will have a valid, effective and ethical model of teacher preparation.

2) Methods/Data Sources

Participants were 63 candidates enrolled in a class taught by the author (45 undergraduate, 18 graduate; mostly female and Caucasian). The full data set—currently undergoing analyses—includes 224 additional candidates from four different universities. Results for these participants will be included in the final paper.

Participants completed seven steps:

1. Take a 12-item survey assessing your self-efficacy for PTC (e.g., “I can suggest appropriate follow-up procedures to help students”; 1 = strongly disagree; 5 = strongly agree; alpha = .95).

2. Read a case study; respond to the prompt, “If you conducted a parent-teacher conference about this case, what would you do to make it a success?“

3. Watch two carefully scripted videos of two hypothetical teachers‘ approaches to a conference with the parent in the case study. Videos demonstrated contrasts along 7 elements of effective PTC (Walker & Dotger, 2012).

4. Rate each model along the 7 elements and choose one of four potential answers describing the contrast between the models (e.g., the teacher didn‘t connect with the parent but had helpful ideas, describes Model 1; the teacher connected with the parent but didn’t have helpful ideas, describes Model 2). Incorrect responses received corrective feedback.

5. View a 1-minute video of the mother in the videos describing the conference. Her comments about Model 1 were negative and angry; her comments about Model 2 were positive but vague.

6. Review an ideal response to the case.

7. Review your initial plan for evidence of the 7 elements (e.g., “My plan included the importance of gathering information from the parent). Identify how you could improve your initial plan.

3) Results

Findings replicated prior work: Participants had high efficacy and could distinguish between models of practice. However, efficacy did not align with initial knowledge of effective PTC strategies (Walker & Dotger, 2012).
Post-case responses revealed increased awareness of effective PTC strategies, especially the need to understand parents‘ perspectives. These responses often referenced the online environment as a catalyst for change (e.g., “I thought my general idea was pretty solid…. Seeing these two different videos really helped me.” )

4) Significance

This research extended prior descriptive work that identified potential avenues for enhancing candidates‘ understandings of effective PTC. Results support the content validity of the online learning environment and its ability to prompt positive change in candidates‘ understanding of effective PTC strategies. An outstanding question is whether these results replicate across candidates from other teacher education programs.

Author