Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Can Posthumanism Embrace Research Methodologies?

Sat, April 18, 2:45 to 4:15pm, Hyatt, Floor: East Tower - Green Level, Plaza A

Abstract

In educational research of any kind, the manner in which a researcher approaches methodological protocols, rationalizes the problem, and utilizes theories is set by tradition, established academic cultural norms, disciplinary boundaries, and perceptions of reality. These limited and tightly bound traditions of structuring academic work are being challenged by three related but distinct movements: posthumanism, poststructuralism, and speculative realism. Each rethinks what research can and should be. Posthumanism questions the relationship between animals, machines and humans, foregrounding how humanism limits thought. Poststructuralism places in doubt the certainty of human knowledge and the legitimacy of the categories and concepts humans construct to shape the world. Speculative realism, also referred to as Object-Oriented Ontology, recognizes that objects share in reality with and apart from humans. Taken together, these three antidisicplinary movements create a need to question the centrality of method, what we refer to methodocentrism, in research and they call for a rethinking of the relationships between humans, other animals, objects, and the intellectual work humans conduct to understand and shape the world.
In order to contextualize the challenges posthumanism presents for research we will rely on the world the work of Cary Wolfe (2010, 2013) and Helena Pedersen (2010) to construct an argument suggesting that “data” is an anthropocentric concept, marginalizing animals in the realm of research and reality. For poststructuralism we will focus on the work of Michel Serres (2011, 2012), Bruno Latour (2009, 2013) and Isabella Stengers (1997, 2000). These authors are all connected in the themes they cover but are often ignored in English speaking debates concerning poststructuralism. In regards to Speculative Realism we will concentrate on Quentin Meillasssoux’s (2009) critique of correlationism and Graham Harman’s (2002) post-Heideggerian philosophy of “tool-being.” We will argue that while these three traditions offer important challenges to the limits of research methodologies, they do not automatically complement each other. In fact, when it comes to poststructuralism and some strands of Speculative Realism the disagreements are undeniable.
Before we discuss the impact of these three movements on educational research we will outline what we mean by methodocentrism. This will require a discussion of the educational process one enters into to learn the “proper” protocols one must accept before accepted as legitimate researcher. This education includes how one learns to construct trusted, valued, and reliable research. In this section we will discuss Maas and Morgan’s (2012) notion of Articulating Spaces, Latour’s inscriptions, and Nikolas Rose and Joelle Abi-Rached’s (2013) set-ups. We will draw heavily on the history of economics, sociology, and the natural sciences to illustrate the rise of methodocentrism.

Authors