Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Action-Oriented Science Teaching

Sun, April 19, 12:25 to 1:55pm, Sheraton, Floor: Ballroom Level, Sheraton IV

Abstract

Objective: In science education literature there are few examples of social justice teaching practices that support students in using rigorous science knowledge to take action in the community (Calabrese Barton, 2003). Studies show that teachers develop conceptual ideas and visions of social justice education in teacher education programs, but do not have the opportunity to see it or practice social justice teaching (McDonald, 2010; Nieto & McDonough, 2011). This qualitative case study helps address this theory to practice gap by providing a descriptive picture of the phenomena of teaching and learning in a science space designed around a set of social justice teaching and learning principles that are based on rigorous, action-oriented science.

Theoretical Framework: Two theoretical domains frame this study: rigorous and responsive science teaching and social justice education. Rigorous and responsive science teaching is based on recent research on high-leverage practices (HLPs) that prompted the development of core instructional practices for teaching mathematics and science (Ball & Forzani, 2009; Windschitl, Thompson, Braaten, & Stroupe, 2012). Albeit equitable in terms of rigor and responsiveness, HLP science teaching does not include the essential components of social justice education including how to critique canonical knowledge and use knowledge to take action in society. To address these missing components, elements from both Cochran-Smith’s (2008) and Grant’s (2012) social justice education frameworks were used as a set of broad social justice teaching constructs in this study. Specifically, social justice science teaching principles were developed under the constructs of endorsing teaching as a political endeavor and taking action against oppression of marginalized students.

Methods & Data Sources: A total of 71 hours of audio and video recordings from co-planning sessions with two science teachers and meetings in a formal out of school science program with 20 middle and high school students were analyzed to understand what social justice science teaching and learning look like in practice. Data were coded according to what social justice science teaching principles were foregrounded in each planning and meeting session, followed with analysis of teacher and student discourse around the science explanation and taking action in the community.

Results: The following assertions arose from data analysis: 1) planning and instructing around a scientific phenomena that students cared about and could take local action on drove the hybridization of the HLPs with social justice principles, 2) students became malleable experts in specific parts of the science explanation depending upon what they chose to focus on overtime, with their expertise being in direct relation to their desired community action, and 3) canonical science was redefined to include both social and scientific components, with the social components being directly related to students’ lives and communities.

Scholarly Significance: This study adds to the limited research on what social justice education looks like in practice, and more specifically what high leverage social justice science teaching looks like in practice. Findings from this study will appeal to those interested in equity, social justice, and teacher education.

Authors