Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

A Focus on Responsiveness and Rigor: How Elementary Science Teachers Facilitate Productive Science Talk

Sun, April 19, 12:25 to 1:55pm, Sheraton, Floor: Ballroom Level, Sheraton IV

Abstract

Objectives
The rigor of science discourse required of students in the Next Generation Science Standards (NRC, 2012, 2013) is characteristically different than talk aimed at eliciting correct responses (Scott et al., 2005). Prior research describes productive academic talk (Chin, 2006; Michaels et al., 2008; Engle & Conant, 2002). However, few studies have looked at the rigor of student talk alongside teachers’ responsiveness to students’ contributions. These research questions guided our study:
• What characterizes teacher-mediated classroom conditions under which students are more likely to engage in rigorous science talk? How do teachers facilitate discursive interactions to be responsive to students?
• How do teachers’ responses to student contributions shape the rigor of subsequent discourse?

Conceptual framework
Teachers’ decision-making impacts the cognitive demand placed on students (Ball, et al., 2008; van Es & Sherin, 2006; Knuth & Peressini, 2001; Scott, et. al, 2006; Krussel, et al., 2004). These cognitive demands can be realized through student talk (Harris, Phillps, & Penuel, 2012; Engle & Conant, 2002; Mercer, et al., 2004). From a situative perspective, understanding is constructed by community members whose thinking and behavior informs how they contribute to a system (Greeno, 1998). We will describe ways teachers contribute and participate in classroom discourse in response to student contributions and how these episodes unfold with regard to rigor.

Methods & Data
In this qualitative inquiry, we employed an interpretative approach (Erickson, 1986; Merriam, 2009) to investigate the discursive practices of five fifth grade science teachers (criterion sampling, Patton 2003) across 21 classroom visits. Each visit consisted of three parts: co-planning, observation, and a post-lesson interview. We decomposed the whole-group talk in each lesson into episodes based on purpose and content (Scott et al., 2006), then coded for rigor and responsiveness. We coded teacher interview transcripts for how they talked about facilitating conversations and managing tensions in-the-moments of teaching, and compared this to how the discourse episode unfolded.

Results
Rigorous discourse frequently co-occurred with combinations of conditions, such as talk moves, visual record of ideas, using open questions; and/or a processing task prior to whole class discussion. Pressing or probing talk moves to help students co-construct their ideas bears out in literature; however, our data show that talk moves alone do not always occur with rigorous talk. The teacher’s responses to students’ ideas altered how the rigor of the episode unfolded. What teachers attended to within student contributions and what they chose to respond to seemed to be impacted by: teacher’s content knowledge for teaching, how they viewed contributions (i.e. “answers” versus “ideas”), and purposeful use of talk moves.

Significance
This research addresses a need in light of NGSS for examining how elementary science teachers are responsive to students’ contributions in productive ways while attending to the demands of content objectives. We provide examples of rigorous and responsive science discourse at an elementary level and describe implications for how to better prepare and support elementary teachers to scaffold opportunities for rigorous discourse in their classrooms.

Authors