Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
What to do in Chicago
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Purpose
School systems and school leaders are under increasing pressure to use evaluation to hold teachers’ accountable for their instructional practices and to support teachers’ improvement. Some argue that supervision and evaluation should be conducted separately so that teachers are unthreatened by the support they receive. (Carnegie Foundation, 2014) Others find that teachers prefer to have the same person provide both support and assessment (Reinhorn, 2014; Yusko & Feimen-Nemser, 2008). This paper explores how teachers experience supervision and evaluation practices in schools that are successfully serving high poverty, high minority populations.
Theoretical framework
The concepts of formative and summative assessment (Harlen, 2006) inform our analysis of the dual purposes of improvement and accountability in teacher evaluation. Harlen explains that the distinction between formative and summative assessments rests in how the information is used. In the former, assessment is used “for learning” and in the later the focus is on “assessment of learning.” While formative assessment is used to shape learning in the near future, summative is focused on “recording and reporting” what has been learned. However, the two purposes are not mutually exclusive (Black & Wiliam, 2004).
Data and Methods
Data for this paper were drawn from a larger study of six schools (traditional, turnaround, and charter schools) in one city. The schools in the sample (1) are “high-poverty” according to federal designation; (2) have achieved the highest performance rating in their state’s accountability system, and (3) offer distinctive approaches to human capital development. At each school, we interviewed the principal, other administrators and one-third or more of the teachers (142 interviews in all). We identified emergent themes using thematic summaries and then coded transcribed data, which allowed us to identify patterns of similarity and difference within and across schools.
Findings
Across the six schools, administrators and most teachers reported that the evaluation process contributed to school improvement. In five out of six schools teachers reported that evaluation was central to their professional learning. They described a balance between formative and summative assessments of their teaching. They reported receiving extensive, frequent formative feedback on their teaching, lesson planning, and student work. Teachers appreciated having evaluators in their classroom often and said that their critical feedback helped them improve. A few teachers in these five schools and most teachers in the sixth school reported receiving little formative feedback and infrequent summative assessments. These teachers, whether novice or experienced, reported wanting more frequent assessments for learning.
In all six schools, teachers trusted administrators who visited their classes often, offered specific diagnostic feedback, and at their best, could model the practices they wanted the teachers to use.
Significance
Findings from this paper will inform policymakers, researchers, and practitioners who seek insight into supervision and evaluation practices in high poverty schools. This paper details promising administrative approaches for using evaluation processes to hold teachers accountable for their work while, at the same time, supporting improvement in their professional practice.
Stefanie Reinhorn, Harvard University
Susan M. Johnson, Harvard University
Nicole S. Simon, Harvard University