Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
What to do in Chicago
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Objectives: 1) To examine the alignment between instructional shifts needed to meet Common Core State Standards (CCSS) for writing in secondary settings and common practice in U.S. schools; 2) To identify frameworks for addressing challenges to CCSS implementation, with an emphasis on the need to individualize instruction in multilingual classrooms.
Theoretical framework:
In the U.S., the view of writing as a predictor of college and career achievement has fueled an increase in emphasis on writing in statewide standards (e.g., CCSS), and in expectations for students to engage in a variety of disciplinary writing tasks. Despite this shift, a majority of adolescents continue to perform at or below basic levels of writing proficiency (NCES, 2011). Given the increasingly disciplinary nature of the genres students encounter as they advance through the secondary grade levels, and the tendency to track students as they proceed through secondary school, adolescents receive differential access to opportunities to practice writing in different genres and for different purposes across disciplinary settings (Wilcox, 2013). Accordingly, it is important to develop frameworks for understanding how secondary teachers might best meet the challenges of CCSS, which include advanced disciplinary writing achievement for all students, including ELs.
Methods: To articulate a framework for understanding the gap between typical practice and instructional shifts needed to address CCSS, this paper presents a qualitative review (Suri & Clarke, 2009) of recent research on U.S. secondary school writing instruction, focusing on large-scale survey and case study research. The review compared 1) expectations for disciplinary writing inscribed in CCSS, 2) best practices for disciplinary writing instruction suggested by empirical meta-analysis and experimental design research studies, and 3) instructional practices uncovered in the literature reviewed.
Data sources: Studies such as the National Study of Writing Instruction (Applebee & Langer, 2013), which includes case study and survey data, in addition to national survey research on middle (Graham et al., 2014) and high school (Kiuhara et al., 2009) writing practices, provide a sketch of current practice. Further, smaller scale, ethnographic studies provide a lens for better understanding challenges and possibilities for meeting CCSS writing standards given widespread practices uncovered in large-scale research. The incorporation of recent ethnographic classroom-based research also helps to provide a better understanding of the need to individualize instruction for students of different achievement histories, including ELs.
Results: Results suggest a large gap between current practices, best practices, and expectations for writing indicated in CCSS literacy standards in the upper grades. However, the paper also provides illustrations of how this gap might be narrowed in increasingly diverse, multilingual U.S. secondary schools.
Significance: Given the rapid implementation of CCSS in a majority of U.S. states, secondary schools are under tremendous pressure to quickly intensify disciplinary writing instruction for all students. As a result, instructional materials advertised as CCSS-aligned have been quickly marketed to schools with little assessment of their appropriateness, given results from research. This review provides an urgently needed framework for understanding the kinds of materials that might help teachers achieve CCSS-aligned writing instruction.