Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Challenges of Designing Digital Scaffolds to Support Research-Based Argumentative Writing

Fri, April 17, 10:35am to 12:05pm, Sheraton, Floor: Second Level, Huron

Abstract

Objectives: Today’s secondary students have difficulty writing argumentative essays. Students appear unfamiliar with the conventions of written arguments (Beach et al., 2012) and they have difficulties considering counterarguments in their writing (Perksy, Dan & Jin, 2003). Using the Internet creates additional challenges to organize, evaluate, and compare conflicting information from multiple sources (Britt & Rouet, 2012). In the symposium, we introduce a newly developed Digital Online Inquiry Tool specifically designed to support online exploration of controversial issues and highlight challenges associated with deficits in key argumentation skills and unfamiliarity with the strategies that motivate them.
Theoretical framework: A new literacies perspective of online reading comprehension (Author, 2013) underlies the rationale for a digital tool that supports online inquiry. This perspective defines reading on the Internet as problem-based inquiry process involving at least five sets of practices to generate essential questions, and locate, critically evaluate, synthesize, and communicate findings to others. This study is also informed by cognitive load theory (Chipperfield, 2006). Because online reading itself already imposes a heavy cognitive load on learners (Brand-Gruwell et al., 2005), the interface of our Digital Online Inquiry Tool is designed to optimize germane load, or effort associated with constructing a cohesive synthesis, and minimize any extraneous cognitive load while supporting key processes of online reading.
Methods: Participants included seven teachers and an academically and culturally diverse range of 170 high school students in Grades 10-12 from five language arts classes and two history classes in Northeastern United States. Participating teachers engaged one or more classes in using the digital tool over three 45-minutes periods to help write an argumentation essay based on reading across multiple online sources.
Data sources included teacher-designed argumentation scenarios, teacher interviews, filled argument graphs, completed essays, and student survey responses.
Assessments: The Digital Online Inquiry Tool was designed to scaffold processes used to plan, locate, organize, evaluate, and integrate evidence for and against relevant claims and ultimately craft an argumentation essay.
Results: Data suggests the tool and related tasks are flexible enough to fulfill the varied curricular needs of high school language arts and history teachers. Teachers appreciated how the tool illuminated their students’ online inquiry processes as they developed their essay and students agreed that it helped them, in particular, organize their ideas and ponder an issue from different points of view. However, qualitative data indicate many students struggled to clarify perspectives, navigate complex disciplinary texts to locate relevant evidence, and decide what claims or counter claims their evidence supported. Students also had difficulty generating the linguistic structures to weigh conflicting evidence, synthesize their opinions, and evaluate the quality of the claims they encountered in online sources.
Significance: This study builds on previous work (Author 2012; 2013) that studied how to support online inquiry processes while reading multiple sources and writing argumentative texts, two critical dimensions of the Common Core State Standards (2010). Findings can inform the development of additional scaffolds and guide instruction that enhances deeper engagement with online texts in a digital age.

Author