Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Longitudinal Analysis of Social Goals' Influences on Engagement During Elementary and Middle School

Fri, April 17, 2:15 to 3:45pm, Sheraton, Floor: Ballroom Level, Sheraton II

Abstract

Recent studies have sought to establish the important role of students' social goal orientations in several key aspects, such as social adjustment (Ryan & Shim, 2008) and well-being (Shim et al., 2013). For example, it was found that social development goals (i.e., aspiring to improve interpersonal skills) were associated with both behavioral and emotional engagement in class, whereas social demonstration goals (i.e., aspiring to be perceived as socially competent or avoid being perceived as socially incompetent) were not (Shim & Finch, 2014). Yet, the literature is scarce with empirical evidence regarding the longitudinal patterns by which social goals and engagement interdependently change across school-years. The current study aimed to examine how changes in social goals are associated with students' changes in aspects of engagement in school across two years.
Participants were 415 6th grade students (53% female) from a large urban area in Israel characterized by mid- to high-socioeconomic status. Participants voluntarily completed surveys during class, four times across two years (approximately 6 months gap between each wave). All attended regular public schools, and 55% transitioned to middle-school at the end of 6th grade.
In each of the four waves social goals were assessed using an adapted scale developed by Ryan and Shim (2008), including 4 items that measured social development goals (e.g., " In general, I try to develop my social skills", α's ranged=.69-.74), 4 items that measured social demonstration-approach goal (e.g., "It is important to me to have “cool” friends", α's ranged =.87-.90), and 4 items that assessed social demonstration-avoidance goals (e.g., try not to do anything that might make other kids tease me", α's ranged =.80-.83). CFA's supported the three-factor goal structure across all waves. Aspects of engagement were measured by a 5-item scale for behavioral engagement (e.g., "When I am in class, I listen very carefully ", α's ranged =.77-.80), and a 5-item scale that assessed emotional engagement (e.g., "When we work on something in class, I get involved", α's ranged=.66-.78) (Adapted from: Skinner, Kindermann, & Furrer, 2009).
The primary method of analysis was growth-curve analysis for each of the engagement aspects trajectories, including time-varying covariates of social goals. Results indicted the changes in development social goal positively predicted changes in both emotional and behavioral engagement (γ = .13, p < .05; γ = .18, p < .01; respectively). Demonstration-avoidance goals also negatively predicted the changes of emotional engagement (γ = -.12, p < .05). The model explained 11% of behavioral engagement variance and 3.8% of emotional engagement variance at level-1. Results were robust when controlling for gender, school performance (GPA), and socio-economic status.
These results imply that students' fluctuations in social goals have a longitudinal effect on emotional and behavioral engagement in school. Teachers and educators are advised to be aware of social aspects of motivation within class, and research should further investigate the antecedents of social goals.

Author