Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Invisible Subjects: Reproductive Labor in the Affective Economy of the School Library

Fri, April 17, 8:15 to 9:45am, Swissotel, Floor: Event Centre Second Level, St. Gallen 2

Abstract

Although school librarianship is located squarely at the intersection of the education and library and information science fields, it is still a profession that exists in the margins. This is due in part to the devaluation of both teaching and librarianship as feminized fields that are viewed as low-skilled service professions (Hochschild, 1983). Esser (2004) notes that school librarianship is a low-status position in the library field because of its history as a feminine arm of the profession, but also because within the larger fields of both education and library and information science there is little understanding of what school librarians actually do and the value of their work. By looking at the work of school librarians as reproductive labor (Federici 2012), and examining it within the affective economy (Ahmed, 2004) of schooling, we take important steps toward valuing their invisible labor that supports educational practices and school communities.

The current narrative of education reform uses capitalistic metaphors and promotes practices such as increased competition within a “marketplace” of schooling. This language is problematic for all teachers in its suggestion that current modalities of teaching are not real work. However, for school librarians, this capitalist-inflected language is at odds with the reproductive labor that largely defines their work in schools.

The work of school librarians is quite literally reproductive. Teaching research skills, information literacy and supporting classroom projects—the foundation of most school library curricula—help students and teachers produce the products of schooling, and thus, reproduce academic culture. In a society where “work” and “wages” are synonymous, unwaged labor is invisible and therefore powerless (Federici, 2012). This work is ongoing, always in process, and makes the visible and therefore easily valued work, possible. In an educational economy where test scores are the primary measures of success, the school librarian’s work is invisible and therefore worthless. The disposability of school librarians is evidenced by the dwindling job market. In New York City alone, there are 300 school librarians currently serving 1700 schools (Fleisher, 2013); in fall 2013, the city’s Department of Education applied for a waiver to bypass the mandate for high school librarians, which would further reduce the workforce.

School librarians are also marginal in the affective economy of schools. Because their work is often equivocated with the space of the library, or the library collection, the librarian’s role accumulates little affective value. The librarian’s subjectivity is compromised by this equivocation with a room full of objects, since bodies matter within affective economies (Ahmed, 2004). For those who teach invisible subjects, such as school librarians, their own subjectivity is placed in question. While within this scenario, school librarians lose their jobs, students and teachers lose support and access to information literacy instruction, critical in the digital age. Through a refined understanding of reproductive labor’s role and the affective economies of schools, we may begin to address this problem. This work’s broader implications include a way toward valuing process-based work across the teaching profession.

Author