Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Investigating Domains of Teacher Knowledge in the Context of Solving Equations

Mon, April 20, 8:15 to 9:45am, Marriott, Floor: Third Level, Cook

Abstract

Although few dispute that future mathematics teachers need opportunities to deepen their mathematical knowledge during teacher preparation, there is little agreement about what constitutes the content of mathematics courses designed specifically for preservice secondary teachers (PSTs) (McCrory, Floden, Ferrini-Mundy, Reckase, & Senk, 2012). Ball, Thames and Phelps (2008) introduced a framework of six domains to characterize Mathematical Knowledge for Teaching (MKT), which has heavily influenced the field’s understanding of teachers’ mathematical knowledge, particularly at the elementary level. However, research on secondary mathematics teachers’ MKT has been relatively slow to progress in comparison to the work devoted to elementary teachers’ MKT.

Purpose & Data Sources
Our study investigated the question of what PSTs know and do as they engage in the work of teaching, such as solving equations, providing mathematical explanations, and responding to students’ inquiries. We analyzed transcript data and written work collected from 12 PSTs during semi-structured, task-based interviews. The purpose of our study was to investigate empirical evidence of PSTs’ knowledge of teaching related to solving equations and inequalities and describe the types of knowledge they draw upon when completing such work.

During the interview, we asked participants to engage in algebraic tasks that are commonplace in high school mathematics classrooms and to elaborate on pedagogical issues related to the particular content. For example, one task required PSTs to solve a radical equation: 1+√(5x+1)=x. We asked the teachers to explain their solution to the equation as they would to a high school student and to consider how they might respond to a fictitious student if he asked, "Why do radical equations sometimes produce extraneous roots and sometimes they do not?"

Results
Eleven PSTs (92%) solved the equation by first finding two potential roots (0 and 7), and nine (75%) PSTs identified that “7” was the only real solution to the equation. In response to the question about extraneous solutions, nine PSTs described, at least to some extent, that squaring both sides of an equation has the potential to create extraneous solutions, because there are two possible numbers that when squared equal the same number (the positive and negative values). However, the PSTs’ reasons varied in the detail provided and their ability to support students’ conceptual understanding. For example, Candace stated, "But then because we’re taking the square, there’s potential that we’re adding a solution that is not going to work in the first part up here. If that makes sense."

Significance
The results of our study provide insights into PSTs’ thinking about algebraic topics and demonstrate how the MKT framework can be utilized to characterize the knowledge that PSTs draw upon when engaging in the work of teachers. However, our study also has provided us an opportunity to reflect on challenges related to utilizing the MKT framework when analyzing teacher comments, such as the blurred lines between the MKT domains and how the actions of PSTs may or may not be an indication of what they know, indicating that MKT may remain tacit, buried within the PSTs’ thinking.

Author