Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Reward and Resistance: The Evolution of Latina/o Critical Theory in Educational Scholarship

Mon, April 20, 10:35am to 12:05pm, Marriott, Floor: Sixth Level, Purdue/Wisconsin

Abstract

Legal scholar Jean Stefanic’s (1997) publication “Latino and Latina Critical Theory: An annotated bibliography” is noteworthy for several reasons, not the least of which is that it identifies seventeen characteristics of critical Latin@ scholarship. Stefancic’s work is also notable in that it recognizes the formative role of Chican@/Latin@ studies in shaping what we have come to understand to be LatCrit Theory. As Stefancic notes “…Chicano studies programs, created in response to student demands mainly in West Coast public universities, united a critical mass of scholars in sociology, political science, history, anthropology, literary criticism, and film studies” (p. 1510) and were critical in shaping critical Latin@ theory. Stefancic’s recognition of the seminal role of ethnic studies scholarship in creating LatCrit does more than recouple the theory with its non-legal roots; her work also recognizes the centrality of intersectionality and hybridity in the Latin@ experience. Indeed, many of the distinguishing characteristics of LatCrit Theory, such as language and immigration status, speak to the diversity of the Latin@ experience.

Stefancic (1997) defines LatCrit as “A spinoff of Critical Race Theory, with which it remains allied, LatCrit Theory calls attention to the way in which conventional, and even critical, approaches to race and civil rights ignore the problems and special situations of Latino people—including bilingualism, immigration reform, the binary black/white structure of existing race remedies law, and much more” (p. 1510). Espinoza and Harris (1997) expand on LatCrit’s purpose, stating, “LatCrits posit that by not complicating our understanding of race, critical race scholars have fallen into the trap of duplicating American society’s foundational understanding of race” (p. 1503). They add, “Critical race scholars see race as a black/white [sic] binary problem. Failure to see the complexity of race leads to failure to understand racism. LatCrit theory endeavors to transform our understanding of race” (ibid). Scholars have employed LatCrit’s transformative approach, both within and outside the law, to expose racism and power and to allow oppressed communities to come to “know ourselves” (Espinoza & Harris, p. 1634).

In this conceptual paper we revisit both Stefancic’s and Espinoza and Harris’ works. With a focus on educational scholarship published from a LatCrit perspective, we conduct a discourse analysis of how Stefancic’s themes and Espinoza and Harris’ charge have been utilized, challenged, and expanded upon to enhance the access to and understanding of educational opportunities available to students of color. This analysis includes addressing underlying tensions some have attributed to CRT, LatCrit, as well as its corresponding theories, such as AsianCrit, FemCrit and TribalCrit. Interdisciplinary critiques include the claim that CRT focuses too much on race, often ignoring other salient features such as socioeconomic status. While intradisciplinary criticisms suggest that LatCrit, as well as other theories derived from CRT are in fact unnecessary because Critical Race Theory is all encompassing. Through a discourse analysis of the most cited LatCrit influenced educational literature, we address these critiques and other questions plaguing scholars seeking to utilize critical race theories to study and improve the plight of historically marginalized students.

Authors