Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
What to do in Chicago
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Feminist methodologies focus on women’s experiences and are concerned with ethical questions that guide research practices. Feminist research problematizes face to face interviews and other interactions between researchers and the researched focusing on the power imbalance between participants. While researchers have power in framing, conducting, and communicating a study, participants’ power is through various avenues such as declining to participate in the research project, denying researcher’s access to information, providing false information, or choosing not to answer questions. (Scharff, 2010).
Scharff (2010) suggests that paying attention to the silences can increase our understanding of the extent to which ‘differences’ impacted on the research process. The examination of silences is a reflexive practice, taken from a stance of power and privilege (Ahmed, 2010). Scharff (2010) examines researcher silences and discusses the implications for research when participants chose not to speak. For example, researchers can enact silences when they do not completely disclose all aspects of a study to the participants. A second silence can occur when a researcher acknowledges that asking questions about specific theoretical constructs or ideals (e.g. what is feminism?) may place the participants at a disadvantage if they do not know what the word or terms mean, does the researcher then move into ‘informant/lecturer’ mode and provide the information to the participant? A third example is when a researcher chooses not to challenge participants’ comments or perspectives, e.g. a participant makes racist statements. Fourth, participants can silence researchers through their body language (e.g. looking away), expression of boredom with a particular topic by shrugging their shoulders, refusing to answer or providing monosyllabic answers.
Participants can also agentically use silence in order to comply with gendered, cultural stereotypes. This paper will examine how paying attention to the silences we can increase our understanding of the extent to which ‘differences’ have impacted the research process a study of 120 preservice elementary teachers. The study introduced students to feminist theories to critique science and education through their university coursework. Participants were engaged in group discussions and interviews, asked to identify and examine when gender made a difference in their field experiences. The professors involved with introducing the feminist perspectives into the science courses encountered resistance from some students. This paper will re-examine the interview, group discussion and essays to identify the silences. The research questions are:
Where there examples of silences in the group discussions/interviews in the project? If so, when did they occur? What were the subjects being discussed?
Did participants resist answering questions on issues related to gender? Did participants avoid answering questions about their perceptions about the image of science and nature?
Were there situations during the research process when the researchers were silenced?
Key References
Ahmed, B. (2010). Not telling it how it is: secrets and silences of a critical feminist researcher. In Secrecy and silence in the research process: Feminist reflections (pp. 96–104). New York: Routledge.
Davis, K. (2010). Avoiding the “R-word.” In Secrecy and silence in the research process: Feminist reflections (pp. 145–160). Routledge.
Kathryn Scantlebury, University of Delaware
Anita Hussenius, Uppsala University
Kristina Andersson, Uppsala University
Annica Gullberg, University of Gävle
Anna T. Danielsson, Uppsala University