Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Exposing Colonial Research Funding Policies and Practices That Prevent the Advancement of Science Education

Fri, April 17, 10:35am to 12:05pm, Marriott, Floor: Fourth Level, Armitage

Abstract

We know that there are indeed many institutional, cultural and historical factors that influence teachers’ pedagogy and students’ access to and success in science related courses. Many, including myself, have documented some of these factors in detail and provided multiple tangible suggestions for addressing them (Rodriguez, 2008; Lee, & Luykx, 2006; Rodriguez & Kitchen, 2005; Rodriguez, 2004; Weiss, Pasley, Smith, Banilower, & Heck, 2003). However, there is yet another factor that remains in the shadows because it is in the shadows where it thrives. It is time for us to expose and have a sustained discussion on the colonial nature of existing research funding policies. I use the term colonial to bring attention to the masculine, western and privilege status funding agencies—such as the National Science Foundation—bestows upon content area scientists and their work (often referred with the masculine misnomer as “hard science”). I argue that this preferred status for funding K-12 education projects led by content area scientists over those proposed by science education researchers not only contradicts the mandates of funding agencies, but it contributes to the slow progress we continue to observe in the advancement of science education research and its impact on teachers’ practice and on students’ learning.
Therefore, I provide evidence for these arguments in two parts. First, I share a phenomenological narrative that describes my experiences working with a team of content area scientists from two universities as we sought, and secured, a major research grant from the National Science Foundation (NSF). As the only Latino, and person of color, in the research team, and as the only professional with actual qualifications to conduct research in K-12 contexts, this narrative exposes how some universities have developed “research grant-mills” units that have only one main purpose: To secure research funds with little interest in actually carrying out the proposed work once funding was obtained.
In the second part of the paper, I share some disturbing data regarding the funding patterns of the National Science Foundation. For example, I discovered that that over two thirds of all of the research grants awarded for one million dollars or more to conduct research in K-12 classrooms in the last four years have been awarded to content area scientists. Even more disturbing, the vast majority of all of these grants awarded to content area scientists did not even have a single Co-PI who was a qualified science/teacher educator/researcher associated with a College of Education. If we expect the limited funding to conduct science education research to have a significant and long lasting impact, should not this work be mainly led by those who have the required academic training, expertise, and networks to advance the field? I share some suggestions for improving oversight and for decolonizing current research funding policies that could truly advance science educators’ work and consequently Our field.

Key References
Lee, O., & Luykx, A. (2006). Science education and student diversity: synthesis and research agenda. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Author