Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
What to do in Chicago
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Purpose and Theoretical Framework:
Debates about the value of explicitly teaching students how to accomplish content-related tasks versus allowing them to discover or construct their own learning leave teachers with two seemingly opposed choices about how to approach instruction. In their ideological extremes the approaches look very different. A direct instruction approach provides students a clear path to success, but is criticized for being prescriptive, reducing complex intellectual tasks to simple routines, and stifling the creative sense-making students bring with them to the classroom (e.g. Aukerman, 2007). More constructivist approaches encourage innovative sense-making and embrace the complexity of real world problems, but are criticized for a lack of rigor and allowing students to wallow without direction in loosely defined learning contexts.
Strategy Instruction lies somewhere in the middle ground, allowing student to use their creative sense-making and problem solving abilities, but directing their attention to the strategies they employ and encouraging them to consider how those strategies may apply across tasks and contexts. This study attempts to describe an instructional approach that provides students flexible and transferrable strategies for completing content related tasks, while avoiding the reductionist and prescriptive pitfalls that plague previous strategy related approaches.
Strategy Use and Instruction is an element of the Protocol for Language Arts Teaching Observations (PLATO), an observation instrument for English Language Arts. The conceptual underpinnings of strategy instruction are related to theories of instructional scaffolding and cognitive apprenticeships, that suggest the importance of the teacher in modeling metacognitive processes and providing explicit guidance and support (e.g. Langer & Appleebee, 1986; Lee, 1995). Prior research using PLATO has demonstrated a positive relationship to student achievement gains. particularly for African-American students (Authors, 2013).
Methods.
This paper draws on data from three previous studies that examined Strategy Instruction in classroom practice. The prior research reveals consistently low incidence of strategy instruction in ELA (Authors, 2013; Authors, 2014; Kane & Staiger, 2012). In this paper, researchers will explore potential explanations for the low incidence of high quality strategy instruction, providing exemplars and clarifying examples identified through the course of these studies.
Results:
Strategy Use and Instruction, as defined by PLATO, comprises a method of teaching flexible transferrable techniques readers, writers and speakers apply and adapt to a variety of tasks. The focus of this teaching is on unpacking the methods used in ELA tasks so that students can adopt and adapt the methods to fit their own sense-making and the requirements of particular contexts. Metacognition is emphasized so that students, as well as teachers, become contributors to the construction of strategies.
Significance:
This study expands the current understanding of explicit instruction, describing a middle ground between direct instruction and discovery learning in which the articulation of student and adult strategies become the focus of instruction. As an instructional approach, promoting a meta-cognitive awareness of the variety of strategies used during ELA tasks, as well as teaching students how to take up particular strategies, combines the strengths of explicit instruction with the affordances of a student-centered classroom.