Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
What to do in Chicago
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
(Objective) How can people listen to one another in order to promote justice? (Perspectives) Allen cites Aristotle who notes that people choose to live together with strangers in political communities for mutual benefit. People then encounter challenges because they have differing desires. This can result in “rivalrous self-interest” where some take away goods from others who do not have enough for their well-being. Often, in the past and present U.S. society, individuals from the same groups sacrifice without consent and without acknowledgment by those who gain from their sacrifices. Most often, the poor and those from the non-white or non-dominant group sacrifice. This is unjust. Allen writes that “rivalrous self-interest” can be transformed into “equitable self-interest” when strangers try for more mutual benefit and shared sacrifice. Friendship as a model for how strangers can relate to one another to achieve justice. She writes, “The pull to draw analogies between citizenship, friendship, and justice derives from an instinctual recognition that these are three of the most complex, and also, most rewarding, of human activities, precisely because all three try to convert rivalrous into equitable self-interest.” (Allen, 2004, p. 137) Allen’s book is “Talking to Strangers” and this paper will focus on the kinds of listening to strangers that are required in order to build a more just society.
Allen claims that establishing trust and dissolving distrust among members of a society can happen when strangers talk and listen in ways that promote good will, trustworthiness, and “equitable self-interest.” Listening to the perspectives of others and showing oneself to be willing to sacrifice some of one’s self-interest for the benefit of others are key. Author, (2009), described how a teacher used certain discussion leading strategies, including ways of listening that helped trust grow between himself and students and between students and one another. This teacher allowed his listening to be “interrupted” and his mind to be changed by the comments and perspectives of his students. This is an empirical perspective on how trust can develop through certain ways of discussion and listening.
In another perspective, (Author, 2013), I described how certain democratic practices can be learned through interpretive discussion. Here, participants share their individual and disparate questions about a text in a process of working together to try to arrive at a shared concern. They then share their interpretations of the text in order to work to resolve this shared concern. Participants practice how to multiply the number and variety of interests that they hold in common and communicate with one another to negotiate differences to accomplish common goals. These practices seem to respond to what Allen calls for when she writes, “Distrust can only be overcome when people manage to find methods to generate mutual benefit despite differences of position, experience, and perspective.” (Allen, 2004, p. xix) (Methods and data sources) The works of Allen, Haroutunian-Gordon, Parker, and Author will source this inquiry. (Significance) It is hoped that this paper will inform how listening of certain kinds can help people listen to strangers in ways that promote justice.