Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

An Expertise Study on Music-Related Argumentation

Fri, April 17, 8:15 to 9:45am, Sheraton, Floor: Second Level, Erie

Abstract

The present study investigates music-related argumentation in a mixed methods design with three groups (novices, semiexperts, experts). Participants compared two versions of a musical piece and justified their preference. Argumentations were coded applying a category system developed in a pilot study. Results of quantitative analyses showed that experts formulated longer argumentations, referring to more categories and mentioning more aspects within the categories. A discriminant analysis showed that the participants’ level of expertise was predicted on the basis of their argumentations in 97.3% of the cases. In sum, the present study provides a category system applicable for argumentations concerning different music genres and first empirical findings with regard to the connection between music-related argumentation and expertise in music.

Authors