Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Advancing Students' Voices: The Role of Uptake in Dialogic Classrooms and Student Perspective Taking

Fri, April 17, 8:15 to 10:15am, Hyatt, Floor: West Tower - Gold Level, Hong Kong

Abstract

Recent discussion concerning promotion of justice in schools and balanced educational outcomes indicates the necessity to rearrange structures traditionally situating students and their lived experiences at the bottom, drawing upon deep pools of knowledge previously considered to be negligible (Sleeter, 2005; Warren, 2005; Duncan-Andrade, 2007). Such pedagogy that recruits and uses students’ multiple ways of understanding definitively supports thinking, learning, and achievement (Nystrand et al., 2010). This highlights teachers’ responsibility to create an environment that prioritizes student voices through dialogic instruction (Barton, 1995; Larsen, 2000). There is consensus as to what dialogic instruction is not—transmission of knowledge unidirectionally (Barton, 1995; Nystrand et al., 2010; Smart & Marshall, 2012).

Still, a lack of alignment between theory and practice persists: what teachers often characterize as high-quality discussion, discourse theorists count as mediocre discussion marked by children taking turns to speak but not necessarily using each other’s ideas to construct a collective context (Elizabeth, Ross, Snow & Selman, 2012; Larson, 2000). Some research has examined teacher sensitivity to and use of students’ expressed understanding to further dialogue and deepen inquiry, particularly in science education (Chin, 2007; Smart & Marshall, 2012). Educational justice’s advance across disciplines through inclusionary practices that place students in a position of thoughtful authority begs understanding of how students’ insights can and should be utilized.

Using developmental perspective taking (PT) as a lens for analyzing sensitivity to student ideas, the present study examines dialogic discourse as a function of teacher and student moves. I focus on “uptake” (Nystrand et al., 2010) — use of a previously presented idea to advance discussion in reaction to demonstrations of understanding — in two transcripts of English Language Arts lessons that employed the WordGen curriculum. These were selected as most likely to contain high-quality and -frequency student-student and student-teacher interactions, after an initial review of 21 transcripts and audio recordings for a subjective impression of quality and frequency of uptake. They were coded using the CCDD coding scheme for student utterances of perspective taking along a developmental spectrum, including perspective alignment, acknowledgement, articulation, and positioning that contribute to deep comprehension (CCDD, 2012). I applied a question typology coding scheme inspired by the science inquiry work of Chin (2007) to mark the type and frequency of uptaking moves and tracked the relationship between both teacher and student question types and student responses displaying PT, as well as dialogic spells containing extended exchanges of such utterances.

Findings indicate the success of specific moves in taking up students’ ideas to scaffold and advance perspective taking, as well as suggesting particular moves that students themselves use in interaction with peers that lead to greater developmental sophistication in their thinking. In addition to an observed pattern of structures supporting this type of participation, both the pursuit of high-quality classroom discussions as well as analysis of the moves that advance them indicate the current paucity of participation structures in which students talk to each other in productive ways. Discussion will consider implications for teacher education, approaches to curriculum, and school practice.

Author