Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Missionary Positionality: Constructing Black Family Involvement Through Teachers' Philosophies of School Discipline

Fri, April 17, 12:25 to 1:55pm, Swissotel, Floor: Event Centre Second Level, Vevey 4

Abstract

Purpose
This study explores the various perceptions and assumptions teachers have about Black families in the context of school discipline. This particular study draws from critical race theory in its analysis of teachers’ positioning of themselves in relationship to Black students and families.

Theoretical and Empirical Framework
Much of the literature regarding teacher/student and parent/teacher relationships has emphasized thoughtful exploration and investigation into students’ background, strengths and needs and using that knowledge to improve instruction and classroom interactions with students (Gay, 2010; Ladson-Billings, 1999). An examination appears to be particularly important in the face of a persistent positioning of Black children and their families as a population in high need of value and life-choice adjustments (Ferguson, 2001). Critical race theory helps to identify the “missionary positionality” as an overarching theme wherein teachers’ values and beliefs are superior to those of Black students’ cultural capital, which can lead to judgment and choices around discipline (Bell, 1995; Yosso,2005).

Methods
With attention to credibility in inquiry, the present study draws from the semi-structured interviews and ethnographic descriptions with classroom teachers and support staff (Lincoln & Guba, 1985). This qualitative analysis was grounded in critical race theory, especially in its critique of liberalism and acknowledgment of racism’s pervasiveness (DeCuir & Dixson, 2004). Authors also attended to reflexivity as Black female scholars interpreting the ideas of white and Black teachers within this research context (Pillow, 2003).

Data Sources
This study draws from a larger multi-year analysis of disproportionality in school discipline for African American students among four secondary schools in one Midwestern state. The second phase of that work included mixed method case studies in four schools with different socio-demographics and rates of disparity in school discipline. That work also included (a) quantitative analyses of disciplinary referrals and use of suspension and expulsion; (b) semi-structured interviews with 22 classroom teachers, support staff, and school administrators; (c) structured classroom observations; and (d) ethnographic descriptions of school features and surrounding communities.

Results
Thematic analyses of those interviews resulted in a number of important themes related to teacher’s perceptions of Black families. Specifically, there appear to be a number of factors that may be prohibiting more positive interactions between teachers and Black families. Those factors include: (a) the persistent troubling nature of teachers’ negative perceptions of and prescriptions for Black families; (b) teachers’ perceptions and prioritization of their own upbringing and values over those of their students and families; and (c) emerging elements of teachers’ philosophies on their role in classroom and school discipline.

Significance
Without further attention to under-developed and potentially damaging theories around race, culture, and access, policy and practice around classroom culture and discipline can remain teacher-directed and harmful to the academic health of Black students. Productive relationships between teachers and Black families cannot occur without unmasking and confronting biases that may undergird choices in removal from classrooms and schools.

Authors