Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
What to do in Chicago
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
As part of the requirements to obtain Race to the Top (RttT) funding, nearly all states have adopted the Common Core State Standards in English/language arts and math, which constitutes a sweeping curriculum reform effort of unprecedented scale (Ujifusa, 2013). The Common Core reflects an effort to standardize what students are learning and when, as well as to bring states to the same uniform level of standards. Resistance to implementing the Common Core has sprung up in several states and locales with critics contending that CCS (1) amounts to a defacto national curriculum, (2) the new standards may actually be lower than existing state standards, and (3) little evidence exists that the common core will improve student learning.
Role of teachers in reform
Common Core State Standards are the first curriculum reform of their kind to emanate from the national level, be filtered through state and district levels, and ultimately be enacted by individual educators in the classroom (Author, 2013). Regardless of the level at which it is initiated, school reforms are enacted by teachers and administrators at the school level. It is at this level that reform policy inevitably succeeds or fails to achieve its goals (Author, 2013). As Prestine and McGreal (1997) observe, “if teachers do not believe in the need for the change, it is not likely to become part of their classroom repertoire” (p. 393). The 4I Framework, developed by Crossan, Lane, and White (1999) places interpretation within the context of the overall learning and implementation process. This framework suggests that organizational learning involves intuiting, interpreting, integrating, and finally institutionalizing, with each process occurring to some extent at the individual, team, and organizational level. Drawing on the 4I Framework, this study was explored: How do teachers experience the shift to adopt Common Core State Standards?
Design of the Study
This comparative case study utilized a cross-case analysis of two North Carolina public elementary schools implementing Common Core State Standards. Data were collected during the 2012-2013 school year through online surveys to all faculty, focus groups with teachers, semi-structured interviews, and document analysis of related state, district, and school documents. Constant and descriptive comparison methods were used to identify and confirm emergent themes.
Findings
Findings from this research support that the majority of time and energy in the initial phase of Common Core implementation was spent on intuiting and interpreting the policy. According to state mandates, teachers were compelled to integrate the new standards into their practice even as they grappled with intuiting and interpreting what it meant. This created significant tension and many teachers felt unsure of their integration as reflected in the frequent use of the metaphor “building the plane while flying it.” Additionally, the time teachers spent scanning and evaluating the massive amount of untested strategies and tools that were suddenly widely available on the internet took away from not only their personal lives but also their ability to put quality tools in place.
Rachel Porter, The Centers for Quality Teaching and Learning - ExplorNet
Lance D. Fusarelli, North Carolina State University
Bonnie Carol Fusarelli, North Carolina State University